"The Tipping Point" and the Watchtower

by metatron 5 Replies latest jw friends

  • metatron
    metatron

    I just got thru reading "The Tipping Point" and enjoyed its observations about social change,

    advertising and communication. The book ends with these words:

    "In a world dominated by isolation and immunity, understanding these principles of word of

    mouth is more important than ever."

    The book makes the paradoxical arguement that the flood of modern advertising, faxes and

    e-mail are making word of mouth, personal testimony more important than ever. People

    tune out the ceaseless messages of marketing and seek instead the personal experience

    of others. I have heard of some people preferring to buy a car on e-bay because they can

    read about the personal experience of others in dealing with the seller.

    I often find myself preferring to look at books on Amazon.com because they usually offer

    customer reviews that are more insightful - than whatever the critics say.

    But what does this change portend for the Watchtower, Inc. ? It's not hard to guess!

    They pump out endless streams of magazines - that even Governing Body members don't

    bother to read. They drive depressed Witnesses to go door to door thru guilt.

    .....but they are (trying to) IGNORE the Internet AND the importance of genuine

    personal recommendation of the "truth" by Witnesses. Being depressed and having

    your family torn apart by disfellowshipping and shunning of the inactive is hardly fertile

    soil for cultivating the conversion of outsiders. Neither does a subculture based on guilt

    and duty attract people as a 'shining city on a mountain'. Accept our offer of a Bible Study

    and maybe you can live on Paxil/Xanax/Prozac/Welbutrin, too. Ain't it wonderful?

    "Tipping point", indeed. Somebody once said that the definition of being crazy is doing

    the same thing over and over again - and expecting a different result ( - and while we're at

    it, I also heard someone wisely observe that "utopias are for only for tyrants and weaklings")

    metatron

  • Cellist
    Cellist

    I agree Metatron. Word of mouth is becoming the preferred method (again).

    The WTS just can't keep going as it is. It doesn't take a prophet to understand that writing on the wall.

    Cellist

  • ithinkisee
    ithinkisee

    That is a GREAT book!

    All of Malcom Gladwell's books rock!

    -ithinkisee

  • Cygnus
    Cygnus

    Man do I ever disagree. The smart people that have money to burn yet are frugal go by word of mouth. The dumb people (read: 90% of consumers) just pay whatever bill is handed to them: medical, energy, food, books/entertainment, whatever. Hardly anybody questions any pricing. I had this discussion with my mom downtown waiting with all these other disenfranchised people and you know, some shook their head and some agreed with me. Partly because I am a LOUD talker.

  • Goldminer
    Goldminer

    You brought up some some very interesting points Met. You forgot effexor on your list of favorite jw drugs of choice;it seems quite popular in our area.But yet the jw mentality states that if you're suffering emotionally because of shunning or guilt or feelings of inadequacy it's either Satan bringing it upon you or it's you yourself who is just weak and not doing enough.

    It's damn if you do and a damn if you don't situation with no happy middle ground.

    Goldminer

  • Cygnus
    Cygnus

    I was on Effexor briefly and it completely changed my personality. I was a wild man with major anxiety and anything would set me off, violently too. If a lot of JWs are on Effexor, that might explain some elders' behavior.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit