Idol Judges

Lady Lee

I'd like to give these judges a dictionary

Randy drives me nuts. Here is a professional man who talks like a school kid. You can count the memorize the comments he is going to make

I don't know man/doll/dog. It just didn't do it for me tonight man
We've got a hot one tonight
It was a little bit pitchy for me but you pulled it together man

Paula - she must believe if you have nothing good to say give a fashion statement

You know I love you
I love the shoes/ dress, etc
You look great

And then there's Simon. You'd think he would have a bigger vocabulary

karaoke
wedding singer
an utter mess
bar across America

Perhaps if they really gave somne constructive criticism the audience would have a better idea of what constitutes good music/singing and really vote for the best singer or at least the one they would buy the first CD

stillajwexelder

I use the turn-off button - sadly my wife loves the show

Crumpet

Teehee - Lady Lee that was just like being there in the audience! Well observed!

I have to say Simon does try to give varied opinions but Seacrest often just interupts him.

minimus

I'm glad Paris is out. Next week it will be Elliott. Then Taylor, then Chris,.

Mulan

I agree with Lee. When Randy says "Dude, check it out", you know he's going to be negative.

I think Simon is usually right on. He says all the things no one else wants to say to the contestants. That's why he's there. He has the hard job.

Paula is just adorable, and tries to be positive no matter what. She's good for them, to at least feel good about something.

LDH

Here is a professional man

Agree....toured with Journey as their bass guitartist for years....he know what he's doing......he doesn't talk like me, but hey at least he knows his business. At least he tells people when they get pitchy or are out of their range....

Paula...sick of seeing her dance with her arms in the air from behind....If she left the show tomorrow I wouldn't care.

Simon....mostly just a critic....doesn't offer any feedback.....that's worth anything....but great fun to listen to....

hemp lover

"I think Simon is usually right on. He says all the things no one else wants to say to the contestants. That's why he's there. He has the hard job."

Exactly. What really annoys me is that Simon sits quietly and listens to the other two judges' comments and they always, always, ALWAYS interrupt when it's his turn to speak. Maybe because they realize his opinion is the only one that matters.

I'm so over this show. Is it just me or is this the dullest year ever?

Lady Lee

More often than not I agree with Simon

Randy and his What's happenin man? drives me nuts too. Wasn't he watching the show> Can't he figure out what they are doing up there? Doesn't he know why he is being paid to sit there? How can he not know?

I know it's part of the scene but really Grow up Randy and speak english

sammielee24

I love the show - but I gotta think that Paula is 'off' in another world half the time. There are times she looks downright stoned..she tries to clap her hands and misses..flings her arms about..eyes half shut..then the next time (like this week) it appears as if she's downed a bottle of sedatives she gets so quiet and is only capable of one word commentaries. I don't mind Randy or Simon - they are who they are. I hope Taylor wins! sammieswife.

TresHappy

Paula - "you made the song you're own" woman; needs to take a chill pill and stop crying at everything; she'd cry at a supermarket opening.

Simon Growl - I admit I find him extremely attractive; when he wears those black shirts my jaw drops!

Idol Judges

Share this