JW's reasoning with their children

by noidea 8 Replies latest jw friends

  • noidea
    noidea

    A father of some teenage children had the family rule that they could
    not attend PG-13 or R rated movies.
    His three teens wanted to see a particular popular movie that was playing at local theaters. It was rated PG-13.
    The teens interviewed friends and even some members of their family's
    church to find out what was offensive in the movie. The teens made a list of pros and cons about the movie to use to convince their dad that they should be allowed to see it.
    The con's were that it contained ONLY 3 swear words, the ONLY violence was a building exploding (and you see that on TV all the time they said), and you actually did not "see" the couple in the movie
    having sex - it was just implied sex, off camera.

    The pros were that it was a popular movie - a block buster. Everyone was seeing it. If the teens saw the movie then they would not feel left out when their friends discussed it. The movie contained a good story and plot.

    It had some great adventure and suspense in it. There were some fantastic special effects in this movie. The movie's stars were some of the most talented actors in Hollywood. It probably would be nominated for several awards. Many of the members of their Christian church had even seen the movie and said it wasn't "very bad".

    Therefore, since there were more pros than cons the teens said they were asking their father to reconsider his position on just this ONE movie and let them have permission to go see it.

    The father looked at the list and thought for a few minutes. He said he could tell his children had spent some time and thought on this request. He asked if he could have a day to think about it before making his decision.

    The teens were thrilled thinking; "Now we've got him! Our argument is
    too good! Dad can't turn us down!" So, they happily agreed to let him have a day to think about their request.

    The next evening the father called in his three teenagers, who were smiling smugly, into the living room. There on the coffee table he had a plate of brownies. The teens were puzzled. The father told his children he had thought about their request and had decided that if they would eat a brownie then he would let them go to the movie. But just like the movie, the brownies had pros and cons.

    The pros were that they were made with the finest chocolate and other good ingredients. They had the added special effect of yummy walnuts in them. The brownies were moist and fresh with wonderful chocolate frosting on top. He had made these fantastic brownies using an award-winning recipe. And best of all, the brownies had been made lovingly by the hand of their own father.

    The brownies only had one con. He had included a little bit of a special ingredient. The brownies also contained just a little bit of dog poop. But he had mixed the dough well - they probably would not even be able to taste the dog poop and he had baked it at 350 degrees so any bacteria or germs from the dog poop had probably been destroyed. Therefore, if any of his children could stand to eat the brownies which included just a "little bit of crap" and not be affected by it, then he knew they would also be able to see the movie with "just a little bit of smut" and not be affected.

    Of course, none of the teens would eat the brownies and the smug smiles had left their faces. Only Dad was smiling smugly as they left
    the room. Now when his teenagers ask permission to do something he is
    opposed to the father just asks, "Would you like me to whip up a batch of my special brownies?"

  • Billygoat
    Billygoat

    Ugh. Sounds like my JW father.

    Andi

  • NameWithheld
    NameWithheld

    Excuse me while I go bitch-slap that mofo. Reminds me too much of my childhood.

  • Makena
    Makena

    The father may also have been progressed to Use of Illustrations in the KM School. Bet he got a "G". What a kill joy.

  • SixofNine
    SixofNine

    Ugh! I remember that one. Damn you!

    I think I may be crazy enough that I would have picked one up, took a bite, and said, "thanks dad".

    Of course, those kids can now use that illustration for just about every non-theocratic activity the dad does, for the rest of his life. "Good shit brownie you're having there with your sports illustrated, dad?"

  • closer2fine
    closer2fine

    In all seriousness - I would have eaten it when I was a teen - just so he wouldn't win.

    When I was in 5th grade the entire class was going to a 2 day camp. I begged and pleaded to go. I had to memorize a 5 minute speech about why we didn't salute the flag. Ok, I was nine years old.

    Ugh, this brought back really bad memories.

    closer

    Mean People Produce
    Little Mean People - bumpersticker

  • lisaBObeesa
    lisaBObeesa

    SixofNine:

    You crack me up!!!!

    "Good shit brownie you're having there with your sports illustrated, dad?"

    ROFL!!!!

    --LisaBObeesa

  • Moxy
    Moxy

    yes, wonderful argument. terribly popular among the JWs.

    in other words, no matter how much merit there may be to your argument, if my argument has any merit at all, even the slightest bit, i win.

    closer: flashback on grade 7 camping trip on which i could not go for no lack of begging.

    mox

  • closer2fine
    closer2fine

    When I wanted to do something like see a PG13 movie, or go to a party or anything really - I would also need to justify it's productive value. Anything time I would say "It isn't that bad" or "There is one little part that isn't good" my dad would say that I had already lost the argument. That once I started into the "grey area" my reasons were no longer white (or good). He said I was trying to justify behavior or activities that were not completely wholesome. Everything in JDub land is Black & White. Talk about living with your head buried in the sand (or up his ass).

    closer

    Mean People Produce
    Little Mean People - bumpersticker

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit