Knocking

by InquiryMan 8 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • InquiryMan
    InquiryMan

    I just got Knocking today. Saw it together with my boy-friend. It was well-made, I think. The two families tales were moving, though not the standard witness family in a way. Their challenges were to extreme for that, but they gave a good impression though. It was interesting to see the non-witnesses relatives give their views as well. However, how well made, we both sort of thought the film was mostly a film of those two families, as well as the legal battles. There was little information on the JW life apart from that. No glimpses of baptism, family study, witness get togethers, congregation bookstudy, DF announsements or whatetwer. Was kind of suprised they allowed the cameras record a prayer. But a well made film. I see now problem on why it should be sent on PBS or other TV stations as well. I DA myself recently, have been four years inactive, been an elder. It did move me to see the KH glimpses, as I am not bitter or hateful. I am shunned by my family, I remember the good things, but the prize of being captive to a cult is larger than any desire to get the "benefits". But each witness or ex-witness have their story, based on their own personality, family background, congregation attitutude etc.

    It seems to me that American witnesses have an even stronger emphasis on family worshiping together. I could never imagine a Scandinavian JW of 23 going preaching with his father.... Most teenagers I know, either preached with other teenagers or other adults, not very often with their own parents... Nor did they sit together on the same row with their parents. Most teenagers sit with their friends. But in Germany, i saw witnesses sitting with their parents, being in their mid 20s. Kind of strange.

  • garybuss
    garybuss

    What did you think of the extras?

  • InquiryMan
    InquiryMan

    Have not got the time yet to explore that materiel. Got it in the post just a few hours ago... But I will sure go into that material as well. It was, btw, because of your recommendation I did order it. And I was glad I did. It was a nice piece of work, not Watchtower-made, and not "apostate" made either, or made by some other religious group trying to pinpoint beliefs. I would call it a documentary, with a human touch perspective, highlighting JWism American side, being quite acceptable of Witnesses, but not totally in control of Watchtower cencorship... (I would think the Van Halen guitar play would by some witnesses be regarded as somewhat off, also some witnesses might dislike the statements made by the non-witness family members, but none of the statements made would be unfamiliar to a witness. It was, I guess, a bit more pro-Witness, than the other way. However, I guess that a non-witness impression would be that the faith is in a way naivistic, believing in utopia and an authoritarian system. American witnesses seem to be more outgoing in a way, their European counterparts more mechanic at the doors. Most Scandinavians do not have any deep religious needs. E.g. in Oslo, the number of non-believers in God, is higher than those who profess to believe in God. Less than 2 per cent attend church... So to be a witness, with that kind of commitment, is perhaps in a way regarded with more suspicion here than in the US.

  • IsaacJS2
    IsaacJS2

    I did see an episode of "True Life" recently where they had interfaith families featured. One was a woman studying to become a Witness married to a man of another Protestant faith. They showed meetings and everything. But the guy really didn't like her becoming a Witness. Her religious friends kept trying to get her to change faiths.

    I've been wanting to see Knocking, but I'm too poor. A lot of others here made it sound a bit biased in favor of the WT. You guys didn't think it was?

    IsaacJ

  • garybuss
  • Dogpatch
    Dogpatch

    I ordered mine a month ago and still haven't got it. Anyone else had this problem?

    Randy

    Net Soup!

    http://www.freeminds.org

  • Gayle
    Gayle

    I ordered it 1-29-07,,paid with credit card (charge already posted on cc acct & have paid that there) but still haven't received it yet (3-4-07).

  • InquiryMan
    InquiryMan

    ordered it beginning of Februaryl, payment registered mid-February, received the copy beginning of March (overseas USA)

  • carla
    carla

    Randy maybe you should use an assumed name and address! You know you are the biggest apostate around don't you? Heck even my jw has heard of you! And he can't name any others!

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit