A new sister in law is a JW, I'm an ex JW, need advice

by EarthyFire 8 Replies latest social relationships

  • EarthyFire
    EarthyFire

    I really need some help here and I might go a lil over the place so bear with me.

    My mother in law is religious, Christian but I'm not sure what kind. I am an exJW, left years ago. She sees the family treatment I get and doesn't approve but doesn't get it. She thinks my family is an exception to the rule in their shunning of me (further explained in next paragraph) and she feels they are just like other faiths that let people have the right of choice. When she asks me things I tend to get too emotional, I'd like to be more factual so I can show her why I think the JW's aren't good without sounding like it's personal bitterness, when you lose your family it's hard to not sound bitter isn't it.

    Enter my new sister in law, let's call her J. My brother in law started dating this girl a few months ago, she was disfellowshipped at the time, they ended up getting married. My husband thinks his brother is under the impression that they are just like us but they aren't. For one thing I was never disfellowshipped, I choose to leave based on the hypocrisy of the religion. My family isn't happy but I've made my choice clear so they are now at the point, some of them, of just accepting it. The others in my family have chosen to cut me out permanently and I'm forbidden from contacting them. I know this might not sound nice or PC of me but I feel my choice to leave was an honourable/moral one, mature and well thought out. J was disfellowshipped for being unremoreseful over dating a non-JW and she seems to not care that she broke the rules. Now I don't agree with their rules but to show my disagreement I left, I didn't just break them and then thumb my nose without committing to separate myself.

    Anyway end result with J now is that she's claimed to my MIL that the JW stuff is all personal choice, she said once she and my bro in law got married she would rejoin the religion just for her parents sake but doesn't personally buy into it anymore. Coincidentally she is now in a different congregation in one area and her parents in a new one elsewhere...personal choice?? To me this shows deception and hypocrisy, the things I was so disgusted with that I forfeit my family when I stood against them. It's disgusting and honestly I want to have nothing to do with my sister in law at all. My husband tried to talk reason to his bro but the twit wouldn't listen, we tried explaining what he was in for and the general response was "we will ignore them" or "oh well." Very mature don't ya think!??!

    I may be going to my in laws this holiday which I'm looking forward to because I haven't seen them in a long time and I do love my inlaws (most of them lol). But I am worried they are going to invite J over and that would really ruin my holiday, I'm actually considering leaving because it wouldn't be right of me to tell my mil who she can or can't invite over.

    So here's what I'm asking for:
    1- advice on how to communicated to my mil what the JW's really are about while lil missJ sits there telling her the opposite (I'm almost 30 & have been in this family for 10 years now so you'd think I'd be the trusted source, J is only 19 and been in for 6 or so months but she also lives closer and sees my mil more)
    2- how to deal with sister in law J in general (personally I'd opt for ignoring her)
    3- how to handle events where we may be together like holidays Any other input is appreciated.

  • BluesBrother
    BluesBrother

    It is hard, prhaps impossible to really get a never-was-Witness to understand. Even if you showed all the quotes from the WT, she would be happy if the new girl just said she did not go along with all of that . People think that you are free to be yourself, as you are in other religions.

    To deal with new girl? try and get along ....as far as you can...

    Holidays? what holidays? dubs dont celebrate them

  • jgnat
    jgnat

    My first take is to leave it all alone. Believe me, I have family members, and I have to include myself, who made some mightily poor choices in marriage mates. If family tries to talk some sense, all they end up doing is cut the lines of communication. Some people you can't save from their own foolishness. This includes your brother. Let him find out in his own way.

    You have a hypocrite for a sister-in-law. Grin and bear it.

    1- advice on how to communicated to my mil what the JW's really are about

    How about experience? Invite her to go to the meetings. Go to more than one, I'd say, three in a row. Politely decline all book studies. Go together to a congregation where some know your history. Point out the people in the back who are not associating with anyone else. Explain their status to your MIL. Ask her to check in to the children's services, prayer groups, etc. If she has any sort of sense at all, she will figure out that all is not well in JW-land.

    2- how to deal with sister in law J in general (personally I'd opt for ignoring her) 3- how to handle events where we may be together like holidays Any other input is appreciated.

    Limit contact to family gatherings. Be polite, smile. If she asks outright what your feelings are about the society, sure, share them. Otherwise keep it to yourself. She's your brother's choice. Leave it at that.

  • Honesty
    Honesty

    What jgnat said.

  • Bobbi
    Bobbi

    There is no easy answer, let her make her own bed and sleep in it.

    Personally I deal with being around my sisters-in-law( yup 3 of them) by drinking large amounts of whatever adult beverage is available.


    Bobbi

  • LoverOfTruth
    LoverOfTruth

    In the eyes of a JW, you are actually worse than someone who was disfellowshipped for dating a non-JW ~ You turned your back on the faith and are considered Apostate.

  • LoverOfTruth
    LoverOfTruth

    I agree with the above advice; let it go.

  • orbison11
    orbison11

    i would leave the ball in her court,,let her serve,,she is 19

    lol

    orb

  • darkuncle29
    darkuncle29

    I'd say first, relax, take a breath and try to disengage your emotions from this issue. If you feel you need to tel your MIL what the JWs do or believe, that's ok, just don't force the issue. How you react to your SIL's actions can only hurt you. Do not overreact to anything she does or says, give her space and time to "hang herself" with. All the while you are calm and collected, and others see you as being rational. That said, I also have experience with family members who've never been JWs before, who just don't get the cult dynamics, and trying to educate them can be very frustrating. I also wouldn't flatly ignore her, I'd just not seek her out or respond more than is needed to meet social demands. Personally, I'd also avoid alcohol, especially if you find yourself holding your tongue. Just take a deep diaphragmatic breath. When its all done, and nobody's mad at you, go get a massage or have your favorite mixed drink, or two, or three.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit