the blurry line between wolf and sheep

by inkling 2 Replies latest jw friends

  • inkling
    inkling

    I didn't intend to bring this up, but I have been thinking
    about a video a saw on youtube a few months ago.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P4XykyYefPQ

    It is a recording of two elders coming to an apostates door
    to tell him he is being disfellowshipped.

    (If you want to form your own opinion about the incident,
    watch the video before continuing to read my rant)

    First off, I would love to know the rest of the story...
    Any idea who and where this is? Some have claimed it is fake,
    setup with actors, but as a witness I can totally imagine
    this scene, and if they are acting, they are VERY good.

    Next, although I realize the man is trying to garner
    sympathy to his side, I don't think he succeeds.

    I see the elders as being stuck doing a really unpleasant
    thing that likely deeply bothers them, and I see them bending
    over backwards trying to be civil to this guy, who in response
    offers them a repugnant dose of sanctimonious patronization.

    I realize he likely feels he slighted by the elders, and he
    might have a good case, especially if he is telling the truth
    about never having received a letter...

    But the thing is, because of his painfully obvious act of
    "playing dumb" I go away with the impression he is LYING about
    the letters just to be a jerk.

    I can't help thinking that this kind of acting out is simply fueling
    irrational hated of all "apostates", even those who are doubting
    from a place of sincerity, kindness, and honesty.

    Someone who delights it seeing others squirm in agony on his doorstep
    is being far more nasty than those he is trying to criticize.

    If I am totally misreading this, please correct me.

    [inkling]

  • blueviceroy
    blueviceroy

    I agree a little thick he was, just like the thick headed whitnesses

  • RollerDave
    RollerDave

    I don't know the whole story here, but I don't think I gotta know the whole story to see that the guy was clearly, at that point in time, really acting like a dick.

    Whatever he may or may not have suffered at the hands of these men, I agree that acting like a dick doesn't do him, or us any good whatsoever.

    RD

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit