Why Witnesses Give Up

by metatron 4 Replies latest jw friends

  • metatron
    metatron

    I heard that a Witness family in my old hall are planning
    to secretly celebrate Christmas. They are third generation with
    most of their extended family in the "truth" - although they barely
    attend meetings anymore.

    Even a couple of years ago, this would be unthinkable. How does
    it happen?

    Suddenly, giving up isn't unthinkable anymore. Nearly all the
    young people in this particular extended family are disfellowshipped.
    The parents needed real help from caring, competent elders -
    instead they were bombarded with Watchtower rules and technicalities.
    While the conduct of their children was examined under a
    microscope - the congregation's elders and their familes
    were given every benefit of the doubt - along with cover-ups,
    lies and fraud - none of which the Society or circuit overseer
    would do anything about.

    Claims of a "spiritual paradise" are wearing thin.
    When the elder arrangement first started, there was every hope
    it would reflect an honorable system of loving care. Instead,
    they've let it all rot in a greedy drive for growth and control.

    We're going to hear more and more stories of long term
    Witnesses suddenly giving up - When Jesus felt pity for
    the crowds as "sheep without a shepherd", this is exactly the
    kind of Pharisaic organization he had in mind.

    Will the Society ever wake up ? Probably not. Maybe they
    don't deserve to.

    metatron

  • outnfree
    outnfree

    God, Metatron!

    When I look back and try to pinpoint WHY I left the Society there is so much there that I often forget things. Your post just brought to mind another: My last shepherding call.

    After commending me for being Sister Humble and Sister Always Prepared to Comment, my loving elders proceeded to give me -- I kid you not -- wait -- I'm counting -- I actually saved them because I thought -- nobody would ever believe this! ...

    nineteen pages!!!!

    (I kid you not!)

    of excerpts from various WT and km articles, with the applicable paragraphs kindly marked for my convenience.

    The articles?
    When Marital Peace is Threatened; subheading: Divided Households highlighted
    Is Obedience Always Proper?; subheading: When Obedience Is Proper
    True Love is Rewarding; subheadings: True Love is Rewarding in Our Day and True Love and Our Ministry
    Becoming an Ordained Minister-God's Way!; subheading: Exerting Oneself in the Ministry
    'Finding Refreshment for Your Souls'; subheading: Refreshment From Doing God's Work
    Appreciating Christian Gatherings; paragraph 4 highlighted
    What Is Your Custom? (re: meeting attendance)
    Show Appreciation for God's House; subheading: How Can We Show We Appreciate Meetings?
    May Jehovah Credit Good to Your Account; subheadings: Knowledge Makes Us Accountable and Accountable for Our Ministry and Rendering a Fine Account as Families
    Be Sure to Put First Things First; subheadings Title Ditto and What Should Come First?

    THERE!!! Aren't YOU refreshed and built up????

    The parents needed real help from caring, competent elders -
    instead they were bombarded with Watchtower rules and technicalities.
    Worse, the [younger, newer] elder was so delighted with himself that he had taken the time to look up and print all this wonderful information out for me!

    We didn't go over the material right there and then (Thank Jehovah!), but rather the older brother (a new elder to my hall) encouraged me to speak frankly about what they could be doing better to help me.
    When I brought up lack of love -- my son, I especially thought, needed some positive interaction -- and the weariness and guilt brought on by the constant push to do more and more despite the real world crashing in, the response was, basically, "it's not OUR job"! If, as elders, we're less than helpful to you, rely on Jehovah in prayer and....

    GET YOUR BUTT TO THE MEETINGS so you can partake of Jehovah's Holy Spirit.

    (sotto voce: We have enough to do with our own parts and families!!)

    I came home, browsed through the articles and shared with another JW friend just how upbuilding my PUT HER THROUGH THE GUILT MILL AGAIN!shepherding call had been.

    Yes

    Claims of a "spiritual paradise" are wearing thin.
    Five months later, I was gone.

    And my disassociation letter caught them ALL completely by surprise!!!

    outnfree

    When the truth is found to be lies
    and all the joy within you dies ...
    -- Darby Slick, Somebody to Love

  • metatron
    metatron

    Exacta-mente!

    There's gonna be a whole lot of elders wondering "why is this
    happening?". Maybe a few neurons will randomly fire and they
    will begin to understand why it's all going rotten.

    metatron

  • LDH
    LDH
    a few neurons will randomly fire

    Since it's the elders we're talkin' bout, a FEW neurons will have to suffice. There's not many to go around.

    Lisa

  • lostboy
    lostboy

    Bullseye, Metatron

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit