Suppose JWism Was Willing?

by metatron 3 Replies latest jw friends

  • metatron
    metatron

    It's incredible how a thought can be so simple - yet overlooked
    all the same.

    Suppose that meetings and field service and everything else
    connected with being a Witness WAS DONE WILLINGLY? Suppose
    it was all really voluntary? Could they survive without threats
    or peer pressure?

    This struck me while watching the Simpsons - Lisa decided
    to become a Buddhist. It suddenly struck me that some people
    follow ritual of all sorts - without anyone threatening to
    disfellowship or shun them - they just do it because they want to.
    No elders upbraiding, no circuit overseers demanding, no
    peers shunning,nothing.

    The Watchtower leadership hates the idea of really willing service,
    while simultaneously telling the world that Witnesses are
    "volunteers". Can you imagine them ever ALLOWING people to
    'escape' to other religions without trying to punish them?
    Heck, they don't even allow elders to resign!(you must get the
    approval of the rest of the body of elders).

    It all reminds me of Communist rule - where they had to use repression
    because they couldn't compete in open markets. I could imagine
    panic amidst the elderly goofs who rule this stupified mess,
    watching Witnesses sneak off to churches with day care, soup
    kitchens, REAL CHURCH MUSIC, charity, programs for teenagers,
    programs for the elderly, ----- you know, stuff Jesus would like!

    metatron

  • Pathofthorns
    Pathofthorns

    I believe Witnesses do the minimum that is required, or at least the majority of them. I think if everything was left to be 'volutary' no one would do anything but a few wackos hoping to outshine the crowd.

    Path

  • proplog2
    proplog2

    JW's suffer the consequences of time reporting and quotas. For every person who gets in 10 hours instead of 5 becaause of trying to reach the quota there are at least as many who would put in 20 hours but stop at 12 because they feel comfortable with moderately exceeding the "unspoken" 10 hour quota/goal.

    I also love to see the quota makers get hauled into the "stoning" room because they got in trouble. There is the presumption that those who make quota are spiritually strong. The whole time-reporting thing should be anonymous. The aggregate numbers is what the Watchtower claims they are interested. The real reason they want a name on the report slips is field service production. Service time is the currency of the Watchtower economy. Lots of service time buys stage time and other privileges.

  • ricoananas
    ricoananas

    This elder wanted to resign in order to be at home with his terminally ill wife, and was asked if He Had Done Anything Wrong. He realized that it was when he became a JW.

    Nazdrowie.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit