Bloodless Surgery To Become A Standard Of Care

by MadApostate 7 Replies latest watchtower medical

  • MadApostate
    MadApostate

    'Bloodless' surgery a godsend for Jehovah's Witness

    By Robert Armengol
    Staff Writer

    A motorcycle accident had left Kalen Stolenwaters with a right leg an inch-and-a-half shorter than his left. Surgery at Warminster Hospital's Center for Bloodless Medicine fixed the problem and took away the pain.

    WARMINSTER - Since opening its Center for Bloodless Medicine barely a year ago, Warminster Hospital has seen more than 100 patients opt for procedures that reduce blood loss and eliminate the need for transfusions.

    But none has a story to tell quite like Kalen Stolenwaters, a 51-year-old Jehovah's Witness who drove three hours from Luzerne County in search of salvation from the severe arthritic pain that he lived with for 29 years rather than defy his God.

    A bad motorcycle wreck on his honeymoon in 1972 left Stolenwaters' right leg an inch-and-a-half shorter than his left. The resulting limp in his gait gradually ate away the cartilage around his hip joint, forcing Stolenwaters to walk, as he put it, "like a hunchback."

    "When I step outside of myself," he said, "I can see the tragedy of it. There's a strapping young man hurt in an accident with his whole life ahead of him. Then, over the course of 30 years, he becomes deformed."

    Stolenwaters doesn't deny the role he played in choosing his own path. Like other Jehovah's Witnesses, he refuses blood transfusions based on his religion's strict reading of biblical text. And doctors had told him they wouldn't open his thigh, replace his hip and lengthen his leg without relying on stored blood.

    Until he called Warminster.

    Surgical techniques for limiting blood loss have been around for a long time. They include scalpels that cauterize as they cut, coagulators that clot bleeding vessels on contact, hormones that stimulate the production of red blood cells and "cell-saver" machines that re-circulate a patient's own blood.
    Warminster Hospital is one of a short but growing list of institutions trying to capitalize on all those techniques, and more.

    "We're not using anything new or different here," said Randy Thomas, coordinator of the hospital's bloodless medicine program. "All the modalities are there already. It's just about bringing them all together into a cohesive form of health care."

    The hospital also has a strong orthopedic staff, making it a good match for Stolenwaters when he decided last year it was time to repair his body and his life.
    At the time, he had given up his cleaning business and was popping Percocet and other pain-killing pills. He also took occasional shots of Toridal to soothe the pain that had radiated to his knees and back.

    "I could tell all this stuff was making me dopey and goofy," he said.

    When Stolenwaters first called the hospital, he said, he had a hunch he had found the right place. When he arrived for his first interview later, the hunch was confirmed.

    "A lot of times, just because we're Jehovah's Witnesses, people think we're like computers spit out of an assembly line, like we don't have our own thoughts and idiosyncrasies," he said. "But they seemed to be really interested in my feelings."

    Stolenwaters saves his highest words for Dr. Anthony Balsamo, an orthopedic surgeon at Warminster and a professor at Hahnemann University's medical school. Balsamo doesn't share the same beliefs as Stolenwaters, but he never questioned them.

    "I could tell he took this really personally," Stolenwaters said. "I felt like he liked me, like he stretched out to me."

    Dr. Balsamo shrugs off the praise.
    "Fifty percent of the work I do is done by the patient," he said. "As I'm getting older, I'm realizing that more than ever."

    As for the other 50 percent, the surgeon said, he got help from the hospital's hematologists - who put together the bloodless regime for each patient - and other doctors who helped Stolenwaters through a week of recovery after the operation in August and have continued to see him since.

    But it was Balsamo who carefully sliced off the top of Stolenwaters' right femur and replaced it with a ceramic prosthesis expected to last longer than traditional metal parts, then linked it to a plastic-filled cup - the new hip. And he managed to do it without ever using the cell-saver machine.

    Balsamo said he believes stored blood has its place, but that the bloodless movement will eventually become a standard in surgical care - one that could save money spent each year on complications stemming from transfusions and conserve the nation's blood supply.

    "I'm going to come to the point where I demand this for all my patients, for no other reason than that I want them to have better care," he said. "There isn't a doctor on Earth who wouldn't want to be operated on in this way."

    Today, Kalen Stolenwaters stands taller than most at 6 feet. He walks normally. He has no more pain.

    "It feels exactly like it should feel," he said. "People are constantly telling me I look like a different person."

    . http://www.phillyburbs.com/intelligencerrecord/article1.asp?F_num=1431538

  • MadApostate
    MadApostate

    Appears that "Blood" may edge out "UN" on this db.

  • hawkaw
    hawkaw
    "cell-saver" machines that re-circulate a patient's own blood.

    This part just kills me. Allowing people to have a "whole" blood transfusion as long as your body and the machine are connected by a tube. Yet, remove the tube and the WTS bans a JW from taking the transfusion even of his own blood.

    Can it get any more stupid.

    Why yes it can. JWs now can have their own blood "stored" and then fractionated to whatever blood product (eg. albumin) they need.

    Can it even get more stupid.

    Why yes it can. JWs can take whole blood as long as blood is separated out into what the WTS considers an approved fraction. Then a JW can have every single blood fraction transfused back into his body at the same time. UNfortunately this technique is not humanly possible yet.

    One final point this story doesn't talk about. What happens when there is a trauma and you are bleeding to death. None of these techniques will save you and of course trauma is the number one problem in the USA and Canada.

    Dr. Sam Muramoto considers these techniques blood conservation therapy and not "bloodless surgery". True bloodless surgury is just that - no blood allowed including a cell salage machine.

    hawk

  • MadApostate
  • teenyuck
    teenyuck

    Unfortuantly, here is a story that will be sure to make the WTBTS happy:

    TEXAS MAN INFECTED BY HIV-TAINTED BLOOD DURING SURGERY

    Sunday, February 10, 2002
    NEWS 06A
    Associated Press

    SAN ANTONIO (AP) -- A Texas man undergoing surgery was infected with the AIDS virus in what is thought to be the first U.S. case of the virus being transmitted through donated blood since new HIV-screening technology was implemented three years ago.

    A spokeswoman for the South Texas Blood and Tissue Center said only one patient received the tainted blood.

    David Autrey, 51, of Chilton, was infected with human immunodeficiency virus, or HIV, through a blood transfusion he received during emergency heart-bypass surgery in August 2000 at Scott & White Hospital in Temple, officials at the San Antonio blood bank said.

    Autrey said he was taking drugs to combat the HIV but that his life was devastated.

    "There's no cure for this stuff, and this (HIV drug) cocktail is no fun,'' Autrey told the San Antonio Express-News for a story published yesterday. "I was looking forward to see all the grandkids grow up, but you know how it goes.''

    Blood-bank spokeswoman Shelley Valdez said the bank had located all the tainted blood. Autrey received the red-blood cells from the donated blood, but the plasma portion was frozen and never used, she said.

    "We are certain that only Mr. Autrey received the blood,'' she said.

    There are no other known cases of HIV being transmitted through donated blood since banks added new testing technology, said Dr. Michael Busch, professor at the University of California-San Francisco and executive with Blood Centers of the Pacific.

    Although the testing process is highly sophisticated, it still is considered experimental and can fail to detect the virus in blood from donors who gave blood soon after being exposed to HIV, he said.

    "I feel great sympathy for Mr. Autrey,'' said Dr. Norman Kalmin, president of the San Antonio blood bank. "We've been devastated by the news.''

    The tainted blood came from a man who was a regular donor at the San Antonio blood bank and who had donated four times during 2000, Kalmin said.

    When the man donated in December 2000, his blood tested positive for HIV.

    Procedure calls for the blood bank to contact hospitals that received the blood, Valdez said. The hospitals then contact the recipients and test them for HIV.

    "The explanation is that the (donor) was recently exposed,'' Kalmin said. "It hadn't had the opportunity to multiply to levels that were detectable'' in the testing.

  • julien
    julien
    Unfortuantly, here is a story that will be sure to make the WTBTS happy:

    TEXAS MAN INFECTED BY HIV-TAINTED BLOOD DURING SURGERY

    I don't see why. If the doctrine is correct then it should be followed regardless of health benefits. Besides which:

    ...is thought to be the first U.S. case of the virus being transmitted through donated blood since new HIV-screening technology was implemented three years ago.
    The first case in three years since screening was invented..

    ..and..

    ... he received during emergency heart-bypass surgery
    Most people would rather be alive with HIV than dead from a heart attack.
  • teenyuck
    teenyuck

    I did not make my position clear:

    I meant that this will reinforce their arguement for no blood transfusions-for anything. I recall my Mom saying that it would be better to die than to catch one of the diseases that could be possible through a transfusion. This was years before AIDS was around. The blood debate with my mother always comes down to "you still might catch something."

    This story is the kind that will give the bros in Brooklyn something else to back up their arguement.

    Of course, if it helps in heart surgery, great. However, if I am in an accident and need blood, I would rather catch something, than die on the table.

  • jacob
    jacob

    wow, on the note of medical Miracles, their was this man from russia, i think it was russia, who had his hands blown of in an exsplosion, six years later doctors transplanted the hands of a dead man onto his arms, now he can use them like his old hands. amazing

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit