what do we learn from this?

by therevealer 9 Replies latest watchtower bible

  • therevealer
    therevealer

    watchtower JANUARY 15, 2012 14 The prophet Samuel told
    King Saul that the time had come for
    Jehovah to destroy the Amalekites. He
    told Saul to kill all of them and their
    animals. But after Saul won the battle,
    he allowed his soldiers to let Agag,
    the king of the Amalekites, live. Saul
    also kept the best of their animals
    to sacrifice to Jehovah. (1 Samuel 15:
    2, 3, 21) What did Jehovah do? Because
    of Saul's disobedience, Jehovah
    did not want him to be king over Israel
    anymore. (Read 1 Samuel 15:22, 23.)
    What do we learn from this? That God
    accepts our sacrifices only if we obey
    his commands.

    What else do you think we learn from this. For example, do we learn that Jehovah is one mean and vindictive god?

  • cantleave
    cantleave

    We learn that Jerkyhoover is an asshole!

  • Shanagirl
    Shanagirl

    What do we learn from this? I think the mean vindictive killer god demanding sacrifice is in reality "Yaldabaoth" aka Jehovah Yahweh.

    Shana

  • xchange
    xchange

    That people should not invest so much of their time and energy into ancient writings for any kind of guidance, spiritual or otherwise . Seriously. Read for enjoyment.

  • lifestooshort
    lifestooshort

    This is the wt intepentation of this account. It just so happens that the interpetation serves wt interests of keeping everyone obedient. This way when they later say donate this or donate that because it pleases Jehovah the flock will say "OK!". After all many ahve been seving for years/decades and dont want all those years of dedication to be rejected because of noncompliance in another area.

  • Doug Mason
    Doug Mason

    Stories such as this one provide windows into the culture of the community that created them. Bible stories are not literal histories; each story is written with a religious purpose.

    These stories reflect the nature of the community, of their belief in the direct interference of the supernatural into the natural world. History was therefore interpreted as actions taken by God(s), and these actions would be repeated should the community fail to learn from the (interpreted) history. The religious writers therefore taught that protection of the community and of the individual required full, complete and unquestioned obedience to God, and he spoke to them through the voices of these religious leaders who were writing these stories.

    Do we see the same thing today? Are there religious organisations that say God will wreak his vengeance on people who disobey his voice, which he gives through them?

    Let me give a modern example: a couple of years ago, Victoria experienced horrific bushfires, killing hundreds and destroying thousands of houses. One preacher said this was the result of God's vengeance against the State parliament enacting laws pertaining to abortion. The Bible stories need to be read similarly. (The fact that there were firebugs and that some fires started due to poor maintenance of power lines seemed to escape their logic. The main thing was to get people to align with their religion.)

    Everything old is new again.

    Doug

  • Larsinger58
    Larsinger58

    DOUG:

    Stories such as this one provide windows into the culture of the community that created them. Bible stories are not literal histories; each story is written with a religious purpose.

    Hi Doug. I guess at one level it is reassuring the Bible is not literal or true. But that is not really the case. Perhaps that's why it is not critical the chronology in the Bible work out accurately per secular history. At any rate, that is not accurate. Bible prophecies are fulfilled in modern times, including the 2nd coming in 1992. Just reflecting on your beliefs, you're living in a dream world, which makes me thankful I have the reality. Jehovah will have his time for getting everybody on the same reality page, which will be soon. In the meantime, enjoy the darkness while you can.

    I am the light. I can only be ignored for so long.

    LS

  • elder-schmelder
    elder-schmelder

    Is Larsinger58 for real?

    elder-schmelder

  • stillstuckcruz
    stillstuckcruz

    ...no comment Larsinger....

  • N.drew
    N.drew

    OFGS I thought God fired Saul because he acted in place of the priest.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit