JW Comic Books, eh, "Illustrated Bible Stories"--Seen 'Em?

by sd-7 6 Replies latest jw friends

  • sd-7
    sd-7

    http://www.jw.org/en/bible-teachings/family/children/illustrated-bible-stories/

    My mom was showing these to my wife--kind of interesting. Haven't had any chance to look over them myself, though. I'm wondering if they throw in anything that's not quite in the account. I would guess there's been another thread about this somewhere, but I haven't seen it. Any thoughts? If I get a chance to look at them I'll be sure to post my own thoughts, but I saw nothing unusual about them, except it's really no different than regular comics--Rated Teen for violence. Lot's wife getting turned to salt and all...

    --sd-7

  • Newly Enlightened
    Newly Enlightened

    A friend of my daughter, a pioneer sister, sent pictures to her showing the great success they're having with the barely illiterate foreign groups on the east coast. I seen the pictures from the pages of these 'comic book' and thought, scratching my head, OMG!

    New all time low for WTS

  • breakfast of champions
    breakfast of champions

    Yes, bible character "playing cards".

    I'm awaiting the Special Edition Holographic cards of Lot banging his two daughters.

    Inspired and Beneficial!

    To be honest: they did a pretty nice job on his "graphic novel"( The kid who drew it will be DFd in six months. )

    Problem is, in this type of medium, bible stories come off looking like the fiction the are!

  • aposta-Z
    aposta-Z

    Just read the Lot story. I like how they skipped the part about Lot offering his daughters to these men who want to do bad things.

  • snare&racket
    snare&racket

    Its ironic that they warn parents about violent video games and films/tv etc, yet they openly expose them to the darkest, most violent stories the bible has to offer. The bible story book has more blood, murder, adultery, crime and death than ANY other childs books.

    i used to like Batman comics as a kid. Those dark and otherwoldy comics had nothing on the eerie nature of these. This should NOT be shown to children, especially with the message of - worship the god behind these dark, evil, brutal acts, he made everything and can do as he likes!

    snare

  • frankiespeakin
    frankiespeakin

    I'm sure these illustrated bible stories shows a lot of the poor psychic conditions of the Governing Body that have a very infecting aspect to it for young mind tobe molded to, being that the Governing Body show some signs of infantile arrested developement in thier edicts I think Freud would have a field day anylizing these guys. They are definately very anal.

  • sd-7
    sd-7

    The stories have a distinct animation style, and even the text is standardized in a way that seems a little too stale for the dynamic animation--it's like they dropped in the text from Microsoft Word without giving any thought to how the font would mix with the animation.

    Two things I notice right away. One, they add thoughts and statements not found in the actual text, like the men of Sodom saying the angels would be sorry they ever came to Sodom. Two, they leave out specific, but important, details.

    In Lot's story, as was mentioned, he offered his own daughters to a violent, horny mob rather than the men who were visiting. Of course, this underscores that women were not regarded very highly in that culture, as I can't see anyone of our time doing that without being seen as an epic coward. I remember always being told that it was very important for a host back then to protect his guests, even giving his life for them--except Lot didn't offer his life, he offered his virgin daughters' lives. No wonder they got him drunk and rode him like a rented mule until he knocked them both up. ...And that's how Lot became a dad AND a granddad all wrapped into one, kids! I can see the legal problems that could arise from THAT illustrated Bible story...

    In the story of Jacob, they omit the fact that Jacob tricks Isaac into blessing him, when Isaac clearly thought he was blessing Esau. A situation that sets up animosity between the two of them--when your parent actively participates in sibling rivalry, it really creates a moral gray area; of course, Esau was probably a jerk and had it coming. Still, obviously teaching kids that it's okay to deceive your parents, since Jacob did it with his mom's approval, maaaybe not the best lesson to teach. They also omit the part where the angel (who is referred to only as a 'man' in the text, but for some reason he's an angel, I don't know why, to be honest, I'm sure I could find out if I cared) takes Jacob's socket out of joint, opting to show Jacob merely holding his side but not explaining why. Angel injures faithful servant of God, an old man, after wrestling him all night. Not exactly the kind of thing that makes you look forward to divine blessing--wrestling a random guy all night and then he injures you and you're limping for the rest of your days?

    But that's probably nothing earth-shattering. I mean, it could have been worse. Although Lot's wife turning into salt was a little unsettling. But it's all safely PG, for thematic elements and a disturbing image.

    --sd-7

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit