North Korean Refugees in South Korea- Film, "Journal of Musan."

by fulltimestudent 4 Replies latest social current

  • fulltimestudent
    fulltimestudent

    This week I'm attending a showing of a SK movie, The Journal of Musan, at the South Korean Consulate in Sydney.

    Before I explain more, I want to say that in general, the South Korean Government, has many programs in place to assist refugees fleeing NK. However, often it seems, these refugees run into a wall of prejudice in South Korea.

    This film presents the experience of a defector. It graphically shows the complexity of the situation, particularly (I guess)) if the refugee had been a 'true believer' in socialism.

    Here's a summary of the story (from Wikipedia):

    Quote:

    Plot Summary:

    The film's protagonist is a North Korean refugee named Seung-Chul struggling to adjust to life in Seoul. He is sharing a small apartment with a fellow defector named Kyung-chul, a "broker" who helps refugees send remittances to their families in North Korea (later in the film he angers several of his friends by allegedly cheating them and stealing their money). While both face difficult circumstances in recovering from trauma and adjusting to a new life, Seong-chul and Kyung-chol react to their situations quite differently. Seong-chul is extremely shy and submissive to authority. Throughout the film he's portrayed as a diligent worker, doing thankless tasks and accepting criticism stoically. Kyung-chul, by contest, has few moral scruples, attempting to steal a pair of pants and taunting Seong-chul.

    At the start of the film Seung-chul has a job pasting advertisements for sex shops throughout his neighborhood; he is repeatedly beaten up by thugs. Seeking more stable employment he applies for other jobs but is rejected when employers see his citizen registration number, which marks him as a North Korean defector. Finally he gets a night job at a karaoke bar; the bar owner's daughter, it turns out, is a woman named Young-sook who he recognizes from church. However, she asks him to pretend not to know her at church, because she's ashamed of working at a karaoke bar and doesn't want members of her congregation to look down on her; Seung-chul agrees not to say anything. Later in the film, when there are no customers at the bar, some of the female employees hear him singing church hymns as he works; after laughing at him for being out of tune, they offer to teach him to sing. However, when Young-sook walks in, she is angry and demands an explanation, asking why he would sing church hymns with karaoke girls. He tells her he doesn't know any songs other than hymns- the implication is that he doesn't know South Korean pop songs and it would be frowned upon to sing North Korean songs. Not realizing he's a defector, she assumes he is lying, and fires him.

    The climax occurs at a prayer meeting which Seung-Chul attends with Detective Park, the police officer assigned to help him adjust to life in South Korea. Up till now, viewers have known he is a defector only due to the numbers on his ID card; now they learn the details of his story. Born in Musan, in impoverished North Hamgyong province- he became severely malnourished and got in a fight with a friend over food. The next day he saw his friend lying on the ground, exactly where they had been fighting the day before; Seung-chul realized he was dead, and assumed the fight had killed him. He became wracked with guilt; the pastor assures him that God will forgive him.

    After the prayer meeting, however, Detective Park berates Seung-Chul, asking why he told his story and saying "Who would want to be friends with a killer?" Seung-chul tells him he doesn't have any friends, and walks out of the church; as he's leaving, Young-sook, who was at the prayer meeting and heard his story, comes up to him and apologizes, explaining she "had no idea" he was a defector. She also offers him his job back at the karaoke bar and says she wants to be his friend; he walks away without answering. Returning to his apartment, he finds his dog, Baek-gu, missing; while he was gone, Kyung-chul had attempted to sell it, but was told no one would buy it because it was a half-breed; he then abandoned it in the middle of a busy street. Seung-chul goes to look for the dog and finds it eating out of a garbage bag.

    The next night, Kyung-chul apologizes- and asks Seong-chul to retrieve the money he's hidden in Baek-gu's doghouse, reassuring him that its "honest money"; he then reveals his plan to go to America. Seung-chul agrees to help him, but says their friendship is over and "this will be my last favor." Entering his apartment that night, Seung-chul is assaulted and beaten by Kyung-chul's clients, who demand to know where he is so they can force him to pay them back. Seung-chul refuses to tell them. The next morning, he goes to church, where Young-sook invites him to join her in the choir; he agrees. That night, while working at the karaoke bar, he leaves his dog Baeuk-gu outside to wait, because his apartment is no longer safe; somehow Baek-gu gets off his leash, and during a break, Seong-chul finds his body in the street, run over by a car. Unquote.

    It can also be noted that some refugees return to NK, an action that parallels the experiences that some of us have.

    here's the trailer

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M07-T9IsBcA

  • fulltimestudent
    fulltimestudent

    Saw the film last night, along with a fellow student from my Sydney U class. We both found it emotionally draining.

    File:TheJournalsOfMusan2011Poster.jpg

    ( Seung Cheul dressed as a defector- would you give him a job?)

    At a basic level its theme is survival. The defector, Seung Cheul, ran away from NK, because he and his friend had a fight over food, and during the fight he kills his friend. That's when he decides to make a run for it.

    But, in the big city jungle of Seoul SK, its not much different. Without the skills required for life in the contemporary work place, he has to settle for work putting up posters in the streets of Seoul. And, he's not exactly a success at that.

    As the Director develops the story, life is just as difficult living on the fringe of a capitalist society. Gang members harass Seung Cheul. His boss sacks him from the poster-pasting job and refuses to pay him.

    The Director's attitude is interesting. Some of the NK refugees live by stealing. Seung Cheul doesn't want to take the stolen food and clothes. Is he naive? Is he too innocent? Or, is the Director saying that he had learnt to be honest and now found it hard to be dishonest.

    A white puppy is introduced into the story-line. Perhaps it Seung Cheul's only friend? But Dr Petrov who introduced the film says he has talked to the Director about the symbolism of the dog, and the Director says he meant it to represent Seung Cheul's innocence.

    Its only when Seung Cheul "adapts" to South Korean society, and steals a great deal of money, which enables him to buy new clothes and "look" western and is thus enabled to 'fit in.' And, at the moment of his success - the dog runs on the road and is killed by a car. Innocence is dead.

    Is the Director being very cynical? Survival depends on adaption. OK, I must agree. But, must I lose my innocence to 'fit' into a capitalist society,*** and adapt to it? Is the Directors message simply that life can be a bugger?

    If you get the chance, see this film. It's bleak and wrenches at the gut and the heart. But, if you are trying to understand the problem of two Koreas, each representing one of the two systems of the 20th century, it may speak to you.

    *** please don't get me wrong. I've managed some factories and that experience taught me that many people simply do not want to work very hard, I therefore concluded that in a communist society, they would not work either and therefore 'communism' does not work and will not work.

  • fulltimestudent
    fulltimestudent

    The Director, Park Jungbom discusses his film (with the help of an interpretor)

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TLO5SnxPaF0

  • fulltimestudent
    fulltimestudent

    This is an Australian (by the ABC, a government owned TV network) production accompanying a group of North Korean refugees attempting to get to S.E.Asia from where they can get to South Korea:

    http://www.abc.net.au/iview/#/view/39977

  • LoisLane looking for Superman
    LoisLane looking for Superman

    Thank you FullTimeStudent, for sharing this film. I had never heard of it but with your encouragement, I will check into it.

    Just Lois

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit