Can You Be Disfellowshipped For Merely Repeating What Apostates Are Saying? Even If You Deny Belief In What Is Said?

by frankiespeakin 9 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • frankiespeakin
    frankiespeakin

    Say a person wants to start making fellow JWs think and open up their eyes so they decide to just repeat what they have read on some apostate site but deny any agreement with what read. How many times do you think he could do it before being called into a committee, and eventually be disfellowshipped?

    How long could someone last playing that cat and mouse game walking on the edge repeating apostate criticism but denying agreement?

  • Black Sheep
    Black Sheep

    If you want them to think you have to ask them questions they think they can answer, but can't, not tell them stuff they have been warned not to listen to.

    It's better if they discover the WT hasn't really answered the question and find jwfacts & co. while using Google to find the missing answer. Better for you, better for them.

    Thinking = good

    Blocking = bad

  • Newly Enlightened
    Newly Enlightened

    YEP! We just had a friend, when a JW elder was telling him about the annual meeting and how the GB must think armeggeddon is really close, our friend mentioned the scripture "Nobody knows the day or hour" to the elder. The elder got so mad that he told him to leave and now our friend is the subject of a 'Witch hunt'

  • Flg8ter
    Flg8ter

    Ultimately YES, here is a capture from the Elders book in the chapter regarding deciding whether or not judiciary committees:

    They leave it vague........if it is intentional or not....doesn't really matter

  • jam
    jam

    Love it, these people are so paranoid. Your friend mention what the

    bible states, "no one knows", and he gets mad. Well excuse me for

    quoting the scripture. That is so funny.

  • Violia
    Violia

    This was how it was in 1975. Mention " no one knows the day or hour" etc and you were clearly not with the program. Many of us just kept our thoughts to our self and repeated the party line .

    Once you realize that they are just another end time apocalyptic religion it helps. It helped me.

  • ShirleyW
    ShirleyW

    Why not, JWs have been DFd for way more crazier reasons.

  • Ding
    Ding

    Any admission that you have been reading "apostate literature" or viewing "apostate" websites can get you DFd.

  • Athanasius
    Athanasius

    If you say you read it on an "apostate" site, this will raise a red flag and the JW will close his or her mind to what you have to say. It might be better to mention that a nice person you met in FS had questions and told you about the issues raised by "apostates." Explain that the person was very sincere and really wanted answers. Then ask the JW if they can answer the person's questions.

  • Quarterback
    Quarterback

    So you want to know how long you would last, playing that cat and mouse game, eh?

    About one month, 7 hrs, and 46 seconds. That seems to be the record. That record, last year, was almost broken by a American, but he was medically analysed and accused of taking steriods. So, he was disqualified.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit