Is the Watchtower Structure Liable?

by metatron 3 Replies latest jw friends

  • metatron
    metatron

    I would think that most strict hierarchy -religions use paid, trained professionals at the

    congregational level - a priest, pastor, or whatever. I would also think that most religions

    run by volunteers are autonomous - so that liability and other problems stop at the

    congregational level.

    However, are there other religions out there that: are strict hierarchies (chain of command)

    AND are run by volunteers? It seems like this sort of structure is an accident waiting to

    happen - because the non-professionals at the bottom can get the grand-poobahs at the

    top in trouble. Am I mistaken here? I can't think of any examples of this - outside of the

    Watchtower.

    metatron

  • Amazing
    Amazing

    Hi Metatron: I agree with your point that an organization run mostly untrained and poorly educated individuals that engage in activities that are better served by skilled and trained professionals, are a liability accident waiting to happen. Today, more than ever, in our litigious society, the leaders of an organization who use such untrained and unprofessional support are taking a major risk. Whether one is paid professional or unpaid volunteer is not relevant to me. While religions are largely exempt from government interference and regulation ... they are increasingly being held liable in civil actions ... and this is where former JWs have the greatest chance of obtaining justice. I would prefer to see the Watchtower Society brought to its financial knees, than to see its leaders glorify themselves in jail.

    Edited by - Amazing on 17 June 2002 9:59:15

  • blindfool
    blindfool

    I'm not so sure about all this. I don't have the experience of being a former elder or ms or even a babtised witness, but from what I've read here, it doesn't seem so different than a large corporation with multiple local operations or branches.

    In large corporations, small branches have guide lines they must follow. The company can shield itself, somewhat, by having written policies on everything from customer service to empolyee break times. The larger the corporation, the more written policies. At some branches, the managers don't even have direct responsibilty over the branch employees.

    The WTBTS is run like a business, not a religion. The only real difference is that they have volunteers, not employees, on the local level.

  • metatron
    metatron

    In most large companies, preference is given to college trained men - like MBA's or other

    professionals. Many, many elders I know are simply self employed/ blue collar types

    who don't manage anything professionally. The Society treats them like dolts - witness

    the eternal 'reminders' about don't be alone with a sister or all agreements with brothers

    should be put on paper, etc. (well, to be fair, many of them are dolts!)

    This kind of structure looks precarious.

    metatron

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit