Confession of Sins-Man's Way or God's?

by Bleep 5 Replies latest watchtower bible

  • Bleep
    Bleep

    AMONG Catholics, confession has changed dramatically over the centuries. In the early years of the Catholic Church, confession and penance were required only for serious sins. Concerning this, the book Religion in the Medieval West says: "Until the late sixth century the penitential system was very harsh: the sacrament could be administered only once in a lifetime, confession was public, the penance was long and severe."

    How severe was such penance? In 1052 one penitent was required to walk barefoot all the way from Bruges in Belgium to Jerusalem! "Catholics could still be found in 1700 at holy wells and springs, kneeling up to their necks in icy water to say their penitential prayers," says the book Christianity in the West 1400-1700. Since at that time absolution was withheld until after the completion of the penance, many delayed their confession until they were dying.

    When did the modern practice of confession begin? Religion in the Medieval West states: "A new form of penance was introduced in France in the late sixth century by Celtic monks. . . . This was auricular confession, in which the penitent confessed his sins privately to a priest, and it was an adaption of the monastic practice of spiritual counselling." According to the older monastic practice, the monks confessed their sins to one another to get spiritual help in order to overcome their weaknesses. In newer auricular confession, however, the church claimed for the priest the much greater "power or authority to forgive sins."-New Catholic Encyclopedia.

    Did Jesus really give some of his followers such power? What did he say that has led some to this conclusion?

  • joannadandy
    joannadandy

    Actually this reminds me of the passage in the Jehovah book given out at this past convention...

    There is a paragraph that states that a guilty heart will make people want to confess their sins and they should go to the elders to do so. So even the dubs believe in confession, tho it's not as ritualized as that of the Catholics.

  • Satanus
    Satanus

    Actually, he gave that power of being confessed to, to all of his followers.

    James 5:16
    Confess to one another therefore your faults (your slips, your false steps, your offenses, your sins) and pray [also] for one another, that you may be healed and restored [to a spiritual tone of mind and heart]. The earnest (heartfelt, continued) prayer of a righteous man makes tremendous power available [dynamic in its working].

    SS

  • Bleep
    Bleep

    Yes it does make sence to dump a load of sins on one another.

    Confessions being dumped on one preast could take a while since waiting in line would take a lot longer than prayer.

  • Vivamus
    Vivamus

    Man-made. Or so my conclusion would be. Jesus may have taught that we should confess to each other so that you would be helped. The Gestapo ways of telltale with the JW are completely man-made.

    Viv.

  • Bleep
    Bleep

    Vivamus said, "Jesus may have taught that we should confess to each other so that you would be helped."

    Me - He also taught us the Lords prayer. I bet confessing to Jehovah would help alot more.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit