Evil or Stupid.?

by Preston 5 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • Preston
    Preston

    This is the fundamental question in my mind whenever I'm in a moment of attempting to analyze the strangest group of people on this planet, namely the governing body of Jehovahs Witnesses. Who are the governing body, really? A bunch of evil (Im not saying old) men who have nothing better to do than to ruin the lives of millions of people? Because of them, family ties have been severed, molesters have gone unpunished, and people's lives have been cut short. And they're still there, without a scratch. It's not just that, it's also that they have a following. They've received that adulation through more support than any of us can ever imagine. It's also a shame that their followers put more credibilty into the beauracratic nature of theire positions than they should. Anyway, I was thinking about this today, and for this first time in a long while I had an epiphany, and I think this is a theory that would gain support from JWs and non-JWs alike. With that in mind, just think about this for a second. The governing body. Just picture them in your mind. This is a group of people who from the standpoint of millions, are pillars of Christian faith, but I don't care what you say, if they suddenly found themselves without their positions, they'd be lucky to get jobs as bloody toilet attendants. Where would their God be then? Huh? God's not gonna protect them for their lack of experience in the real world. And that's the point: they're inexperienced. The majority of them have never held full-times jobs (I dont count what they do now as work), don't have families, don't have any sort of credible secular education, and have been receiving a salary from 6 million loyalists from the time they've been declared superior Christians until now. They're like, well, kids. And, unfortunately, they can make any sort of law they can get away with. It's like you let your infant son run the house with servants at this beck and call. If you do that, trouble will ensue. And, if God does provide them with his holy spirit, which is doubtful, than that tool can only be considered useful within the context of their world experience (not that much). What do they have to fall back on when they don't advise a parent to take the evil bastard who molested her son to the police. Nothing. They're not in that sort of position to make such a decision. If you want you're leaky faucet fixed, do you go to the plumber, or a person who knows nothing about it? The govering body have been giving advice about what to do with your very life! Its like the commercial where the guy is giving advice, and the confidence is all due to his staying at a hotel. And that's my theory. They only appear smart because they speak well. But this, unfortunately, doesn't make up for the fact that they don't have a clue about what's going on in the real world. (ever see the movie BEING THERE?) So what do you think? Is the damage they cause more a result to their inexperience or them being plain evil?

    Edited for bad spelling

    Edited by - Preston on 24 September 2002 20:33:58

  • patio34
    patio34

    Hi Preston,

    IMO, it doesn't really matter if the damage they've caused is due to being evil or stupid. If it's stupidity, it's criminal stupidity. They're culpable either way.

    Pat

  • Preston
    Preston

    Thank you Pat, I was really worried there for a sec when nobody answered my post. You're right, it's kind of like being "criminally negligent" if they are truly that ignorant. They're sill at fault.

  • joannadandy
    joannadandy

    Preston--good topic (I won't have to beat you with a stick now, unless you're into that)

    And I agree. I never really thought of them as lacking in a real-world setting. This is the number one complaint with all clergy is that they are so seperated they don't get it. I believe Sir Thomas Moore was railing agaist the clergy for this very reason back in the 1500's. They were cloistered lunatics looking only to better themselves and had no concept of what the people were facing because they cut themselves off from the people. A very un-Christlike behavior.

    However, while we peaons applaud this kind of attitude the clergy/governing body only use this attitude to fuel their cause. Follow me down this dusty trail. We are wordly. We are not pure. Perhaps we have trials because we are turning our backs on the true faith. Meanwhile, why would they want a "real-world" view, if the world is corrupt and evil? If we would only listen to them--the holy spirit filled few, we could be as happy and fullfilled as them.

    Theyre not in that sort of position to make such a decision

    No they are not--they are not trained psychologists, lawyers, judges, family conselors, etc. But they have HOLY SPIRIT--which negates any wordly authority. They have THE authority from JEHOVAH, which is all powerful in comparison with the feeble authority and knowledge of study that mere mortals have.

    So while I get what you are saying, and most people here will agree with you--dubs will never get it. They believe these men do have the position and expertise to tell them how to lead their lives. If they are un-happy they are told to pray more earnestly. Wait on Jehovah. And they really believe if they shun their family, support the JW name in the face of "pedophile propoganda" Jehovah will bless them, and they will have paradise eternal.

    You are using a logic that does not compute with this illogical bunch of people.

  • Preston
    Preston

    Thanks joanna, that's pretty much what I think too (except the "beating" part, for I prefer whips). It's impossible to reason with a JW because in their minds God only backs the governing body, so they're justified to do anything, pretty much...

  • LyinEyes
    LyinEyes

    Preston, you are right they don't know what it is like to be in the real world. We knew a man who was in Bethel for over 7 yrs. He and my hubby grew up together. The boy was sheltered his entire life anyway, being the only son and his older dad was very protective. He was one of those who didnt get into sports, or do anything at school. He was the perfect JW kid. He was the perfect Bethelite( I say the word perfect , as theJW's would look at them. ) When he came home to serve in the local congregation and look for a wife, things at home had changed alot for us. We had a child. We had to work, we had bills, etc. etc. just real life stuff.

    He had no clue the changes in us, he was just like he was when he left still 18, while we felt 40 something, and we were young.

    Not all JW's are evil, but the GB is another story. They claimed to be spirit directed by God and use it to ruin lives. They have alot to answer for and I feel the time is about to happen for them.

    Since they live in their perfect little world up there, lilke you said, no kids, family to mention, bills to pay, etc. they have plenty of time to do the job they are there for: tell others how to cope in the world. As if they have a clue!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    You are right on about them Preston, they have no right, they just take it.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit