Hallmarks of the Totalitarian State

by refiners fire 7 Replies latest jw friends

  • refiners fire
    refiners fire

    I was just skimming a book by Max Eastman, a disputer against Stalinism in the 30s and 40s. Some interesting things are listed in his book "Stalins Russia" identifying the hallmarks of the Cult of Stalin....

    pages 82 through 86:

    Sign 1 ) " Nationalistic emotion is hysterically exalted. Patriotism is the supreme law of life"

    Doesnt reaaly apply to the dubs does it? But then , the dubs dont run the state. If they did maybe it would apply.

    Sign 2) "A single party, disciplined, centrally controlled, having a monopoly of the field"

    Well the dubs only recognize one religion dont they? Its centrally controlled, It strives to monopoloize control over the members.

    sign 3) "Dissenting opinion is coerced by means of intimidation".

    Well the dubbies certainly dont allow dissent do they?

    Sign 4) "The church is allowed to exist but even its God must recognize the superiority of the party"

    Well just invert this one brothers, the state is allowed to exist but must recognize the superior authority of the Watchtower God.

    Sign 5) "The new state religion finds its focus in the leader who becomes to all intents and purposes, a God".

    Well the Watchtower "channel" isnt God, but they certainly SPEAK for Him!

    Sign 6) "Anti intellectualism becomes a public policy" The writer says " Stalin didnt exile his intellectuals. He had them SHOT"

    Odd thing about anti intellectualism, cults, very often when starting out,seek to recruit intellectuals and university students, but once the cult is established the trend usually reverses.

    Sign 7) "The physical detruction of books, records, and a rewriting of history to make it fit the needs of the moment." He says "Stalinist history falsification makes Hitlers public book burnings look like an independence day celebration"

    Nothing to be said on that one I think.

    Sign 8) "An attack upon Science"

    Well what do you know? The dubbies are anti science too. Something funny going on here brothers....

    Sign 9) "The manipulation of public opinion is substituted for its enlightenment."

    Hmmmm.

    Sign 10 ) "Cultural Isolation"

    Yes. The Witnesses Isolate and "Seperate" themselves.

    Sign 11) "Control of creative art". Art, Music, theatre.....Everything for public consumption must confirm to party dogma.

    The dubs dont control the Arts, if they controlled the State, doubtless they would! So they have to be content to "discourage" them.

    Sign 12) " Immoralism in two forms, Political lying and Hypocricy" on the part of the ruling elite.

    Well the dubbies say one thing and do another under concealment dont they? So I guess the criteria applies.

    Sign 13 doesnt apply. Im not aware the Watchtower sanctions assassination of opponents!

    Sign 14) " The state incites the population to bait and destroy some public enemy"

    Well, the witnesses dont seek to destroy their enemies. Gods gonna do that for them. But they certainly view all outside the safe boundaries of the organization as "enemy territory".

    Hmmmm. Skip a few cause im getting tired..

    Sign 19) "Woman is relegated to a subordinate position".

    Sign 21) "Endless use of Slogans...Proletarian, revolutionary socialist, Capitalist world, workers, peasants" etc.

    Well BROTHERS and SISTERS I think the ORGANIZATION led by the REMNANT of the FAITHFULL and DISCREET SLAVE CLASS certainly engages in that activity too!

    Interesting.

    Edited by - refiners fire on 27 November 2002 2:20:30

  • magzy28
    magzy28

    hi this is a test

  • refiners fire
  • Satanus
    Satanus

    Well, i've enjoyed you communism synopsis. There is so much of history to study yet, and short articles help to fit in another piece of the puzzle.

    SS

  • refiners fire
    refiners fire

    SS

    Id like to do a comprehensive post on History fabrication under Stalin.

    The pattern is the same as the dubs, its directed at proving the channel always right and burying false predictions.

    But its proving pretty hard to compile, theres the language problem for a start, terms like "proletarian" instead of "brother" , "Capitalist" instead of "worldling". And there are all types of "worldlings" and "enemies" in Stalinism. Theres "Menshevik" , "Stakhanovite". "Trotskyite" . "Kulak" etc. Its pretty confusing for the uninitiated. But in fact, the parallels in method and intent are striking.

    Thanks for your interest.

  • greven
    greven

    Thanx RF!

    Nice post again. the dubbies certainly fit the profile. I was reading a book by Terry Pratchett lately called "interesting times". it is loosly based on imperial China and while reading I found a lot of parallels with the borganization. If the dubbies would be a political party it would indeed be a Totalitarian State.

    keep up the good work!

    Greven.

  • refiners fire
    refiners fire

    Here are some choice excerpts from a book about Cult mind control.

    The chapter heading is " the technology of mind control".

    ..." A cult has a living leader. He is not elected by man but is appointed by God, unless he, conveniently, happens to BE God....After he recieves his revelation he tries to awaken mankind and suffers again by being misunderstood and persecuted....the press, independant researchers and government commissions tell lies about him......

    " Cults disparage the society that allows them to thrive, the conventional family, professionals, expressions of cultural prosperity. They say that their sacred mission is to preserve the eroding family unit in modern society. What they actually do is break apart the nuclear family to get members for the cult family.If a cult has no hope of roping in a relative of the already hooked member the member is required to sever all ties"....

    "The legacy of human expression has no place in the cult milieu.Cults do not go to the trouble of burning books, shooting university professors, or outlawing music. ...They simply blot them out of the perception of the cultist by declaring them at cross purposes with God because they are part of the culture wherein the 'enemy' thrives"....

    "The strength of a cult, the strength of its cohesiveness....is directly proportional to the clarity, imminence and power of the imagined enemy"....

    "Once trained to follow without thinking, members will believe anything they are told, even in the face of contradictory evidence. The doctrines and communiques of policy often change radically to suit the immediate goals of the leader, so tracts and holy books are periodically withdrawn from circulation and rewritten.".....

    " Incoming information is completely biased and no contradictory information may be presented or discussed. Anyone persisting in trying to present unwanted information is discreetly removed and barred further entry".

    ..." the fear of not measuring up to the cults unattainable standard where there are only two marks on the scale: perfection and failure."....

    Hey this woman isnt talking about the dubs. The book is called "DARK SIDE OF THE MOONIES"

  • expatbrit
    expatbrit

    Interesting list Refiners.

    You commented that point 1 (about Nationalism) doesn't apply to the dubs. In fact I think it does, if you consider the dubs to be a form of nation. They do sometimes refer to themselves in that way. Thus, they have extreme emotional patriotism to their own nation.

    Also, for point 13 on assassination, they may not physically do this, but mentally and emotionally they sure do!

    Expatbrit

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit