what's in a name?

by peacefulpete 6 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • peacefulpete
    peacefulpete

    Perusing the Insight books years ago it occured to me how many names of Bible charactors seemed prophetic. That is, their name matched to the story they appeared in. "Achan" for example means "bringer of trouble" and sure enough he was. It would have seemed an easy thing to identify the trouble maker in the story yet noone seemed to know it was Achan until Jehovah pointed him out. I pondered, did God inspire his parents to name him "trouble maker" or was Achan not his real name? This pattern of names fitting the charactors role in the story is repeated over and over. (Moses=drawn from the water, Ishmael=God hears, As the story says He did when Ishmael was dying in the desert, Miriam=rebellious, etc.) Sometimes the connection is more subtle but dozens of names refer to roles in the story or to geographical places where the charactor is said to be from. Sometimes the stories surrounding the charactor were abbreviated in the Bible version and were preserved only in extra-bibical literature. I have since also found that secular reference works reveal the meaning of the names far more often than the Insight Volumes. What does this imply? I can see it three ways, either the names are author's creations, the stories were fictional or Jehovah is playing puppetry with humans. Anyway you look at it it's troubling.

    Edited by - peacefulpete on 9 January 2003 11:9:6

    Edited by - peacefulpete on 9 January 2003 11:42:36

    Edited by - peacefulpete on 9 January 2003 14:41:6

  • auntiem
    auntiem

    The names in this story have been changed to protect the guilty and............

    Hugs!

    aUnTiE M

  • Anita
    Anita

    Okay, no verses to quote or any of that supporting evidence. But, remember in Daniel that when they went to Bablyon their names were changed upon arriving. Also Abraham's name had previously been Abram. Many other indications of flat out name changes. It seems to have been a generally accepted and common practice to change one's name as your life changed it course. That is all it is. No big plot hun :)

    Anita

  • NameWithheld
    NameWithheld

    Well, since the bible books that deal w/ early Isreal's history are a collection of myths, fables, and lore, and are at best exagerations of true events, it doesn't seem illogical that the names of the characters would be made to fit the story ...

  • peacefulpete
    peacefulpete

    Anita...The times in the Bible when names were changed it often reflected a change in the role of the charactor. The example you gave illustrates this. The hebrew names Azariah means "Jehovah has helped" Mishael means "who belongs to God?" and Hananiah means "Jehovah has been gracious". These names then represent the plot of the story. The giving of Babylonian names which praised other gods is also part of the tale as it amounted to a battle of Gods. The WT has called the names given at birth "prophetic" (Ishmael and Ezekiel) in their writings.
    I will not expound too much but other names also had origins in other mythologies. For instance ABRAM is BRAHMA in Indu-Hittite mytholgy. The legendary progenitor of the Brahmins.

    Edited by - peacefulpete on 9 January 2003 14:36:25

  • metatron
    metatron

    This is a fair point to think about. How did anyone actually have a name like Caleb (dog)
    Cozbi (voluptuousness), or Ishbosheth (man of shame)?

    Try to imagine really going thru life with anyone of these names.

    metatron

  • Country Girl
    Country Girl

    I dunno... I always thought Bill Cozbi was kinda voluptuous. <wink>

    CG

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit