numbers 31 poll

by jerome 5 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • jerome
    jerome

    In numbers 31 God orders the Isrealites to to attack the Midianites apparently because hes fed up with them.
    Here are the points to consider.

    1) All the adult males are killed to begin with.
    2) The spare the women and children.
    3) God gets mad because they spared the women and children and he causes a plague.
    4) They kill all the females who have "known" an man by lying with him.
    5) The kill the male childre.
    6) Finally they keep the females who have not known a man by lying with him.

    Here is a link to a site that discusses the problem in limited detale.
    http://www.apologeticspress.org/abdiscr/abdiscr69.html
    (If you have a link to a watchtower article that discusses the matter please post it.)

    After reading that explaination of what happened do you:

    a) Find it totally just and acceptable
    - it will not afect your faith negatively.
    - [insert what you wish here].

    b) Need a better explaination
    - feel unconfortable with it at first glance if I dont get a darn good explaniation for this it will seriously affect my faith.

    c) [I] Find it totally unjustifiable and unacceptable
    - [insert what you wish here].

    d) Undecided
    - Mabe the bible has a few problems but i'm not going to give up on it that easy.

    Any comments on this would also be nice especially after a) and c).

    Oh by the way I vote:

    C [I] Find it totally unjustifiable and unacceptable - I dont think that there is a good enough anwser for this anywhere but that wont stop me from listening.

    Edited to improve readibility.

    Edited by - jerome on 11 January 2003 3:2:55

  • Satanus
    Satanus

    Hi jerome

    Nice of you to drop in.

    C) The jews were acting like animals, lions in particular. When a male lion succeeds in defeating a another male who has a pride (group of females and young), he kills all the young ones, and maybe the males. Then he reimpregnates the females. Actually, the jews were worse than lions. This was commanded by their god. Their god was worse than a wild animal.

    SS

    Edited by - saintsatan on 11 January 2003 3:23:47

  • jerome
    jerome

    Hi SS

    Just dropping in for a while, I mostly lurk now.

  • jerome
    jerome

    Just bringing this back to the top.

  • jerome
    jerome

    Mabe the right people havent seen this thread.

  • SLOAN
    SLOAN

    C!

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit