The Elder's Choice~"Care for his Own" or Save Face and Retain Congregation Privileges?

by TMS 3 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • TMS
    TMS

    "But if any provide not for his own, and specially for those of his own house, he hath denied the faith, and is worse than an infidel." 1 Timothy 5:8, KJV

    The scriptural principle above is not followed by Jehovah's Witnesses if a child's presence in the home is a threat to retaining congregation privileges. Even if God's so-called "word" calls for caring for one's family, it's more important for a JW to simply maintain the appearance, if not the reality, of "presiding over his household in a fine way," so as to keep serving as an elder.

    My brother-in-law, after falling to get appointed as an elder for a number of years, finally got his wish about twenty years ago. It was a running joke, even among the non-JW side of the family that "R wants to be an elder so badly," as my Baptist mother-in-law used to say.

    Once appointed, R's life became complicated by three children, all with bipolar symptoms. The kids, all good looking, athletic and intelligent, succumbed to the illness as they reached their twenties, now functioning with limited skill sets to live independently. Each child has presented a slightly different challenge to their elder father as he tries to maintain his image in the congregation as an elder meeting scriptural requirements (Watchtower rules).

    The oldest child, now 32, was never baptized, despite an urgent bullrush by the local elders when he was 15.

    "They told me that not getting baptized would not protect me at Armageddon, because Jehovah knew I had the knowledge to do the right thing and refused to act on that knowledge. I told them I would never submit to baptism because I didn't want to be disfellowshipped," the young man told me recently.

    He was correct, of course, as his life since has been full of so-called disfellowshipping offenses, but his non-baptized state has given him family access. Recently released from prison, he went straight to his folks, who tried furiously to find other accommodations for him. Eventually, the young man found food and shelter with a cousin, who is also an ex-JW.

    The second son, at 18 or so the apparent congregation role model on a fast track to Bethel, is now about 30, having paid dearly for his mistake of baptism, by being estranged from his family for a number of years. I visited with him at a food store a couple of years ago just before his second or third attempt at reinstatement. Proudly, he showed me his wrist, displaying a tattoo of the tetragrammaton.

    "I'm going to show this to the elders to prove to them my devotion to Jehovah," he goofily told me at the time. He was eventually reinstated, despite the tattoo.

    This boy's life has continued to spin wildly out of control, despite now being a JW "in good standing." He and his wife, the daughter of another local elder, live off of social security checks for mental disability, but supplement that income with con artistry, fake GoFund requests, stealing credit and debit card information, etc. Both are currently in Paris on vacation, despite having almost no income.

    I've had little contact, in recent years, with the youngest child, a daughter, now in her late twenties. We've seen her once at an art gallery, arm in arm with her non-JW boyfriend, and once more at a club featuring live music. She did not make eye contact either time and we didn't approach. She lives in her own government-subsidized apartment, keeping her secret life separate from the family.

    She, like her older brother, successfully resisted baptism, but has continued in school, now pursuing her doctorate, most likely in education. She's never held a job, although has done some non-paying work in fashion.

    Because of her unusual beauty, she's traveled the world escorted by various men, so much so, that she gifted a recent vacation to her parents paid for by her frequent flier miles. She may also have used this to pay for her brother's trip to Paris. I don't know.

    The daughter, still dependent on her parents in several ways, frequently attends meetings as an "interested person." even making an occasional comment. In comments made on a YouTube video, she describes herself as "leaning toward Buddhism." Because of her skill set in "playing the role" and never being baptized, she's free to navigate the JW scene as she sees fit.

    Meanwhile, the elder and his wife, my brother and sister-in-law, live in their two story, "empty nest" home. The upstairs bedrooms are empty and the congregation privileges remain preserved. It's all about priorities.


  • scoobydont
    scoobydont

    The JW world is up there with the most bizarre bubbles of self-deception. In the bubble, one's cognition is heavily warped and everything around becomes make-believe as rational thinking is buried away, under layers of sham teachings and dubious accolades from fellow JWs. I suppose that is what the experts might describe as "cult mentality".

    I knew quite a few brothers and sisters whose family lives ran like a badly scripted horror movie. Yet, these ones turned their back on pressing family issues or, in some cases, "sacrificed" family members just to be seen as "putting Jehovah first". Nice job !

    When I look back at all the pretty sisters and handsome brothers, now old and "past it", who never got hitched because they were either looking for a non-existent super-spiritual partner or simply because Armageddon was "just around the corner", I feel nothing but genuine sadness for all those people who I now view as victims of a subculture of self-glorification and dubious peer endorsement, a good number of them egged on by deluded JW parents and relatives whose primary concern was self-image in the congregation. Some of these 40-something year-old brothers and sisters have found new roles as carers for their elderly JW parents who played a major role in "herding" them into this rather miserable corner of life. And the Watchtower society comes out as the winner !

    Seems to me like your unbaptised nephew and niece are smarter than you appear to give them credit for. They have their parents and the JW organisation well sussed and they're playing them at their game. After all, hasn't the Watchtower society learned to eat and yet have its cake ? Why shouldn't your nephew and niece do the same ? They have never been baptised, so they get away with all sorts and dad's position and privileges in the congregation remain unthreatened. Sounds like a deal all parties should be happy with !

    And as to the inference about the nephew and niece fleecing the state, well, what can one say, really ? Donal Trump, today, prides himself as being smart for successfully evading taxes for 18 years ! It seems to me that same system which allowed Trump to get away with tax evasion also makes it possible for your nephew and niece to support their rather relaxed lifestyle with recourse to state funds. I do not support tax evasion nor do I support a "creaming" of state funds, but if your nephew and niece have done so, legally, what can you and I say ?

  • TMS
    TMS

    "Seems to me like your unbaptised nephew and niece are smarter than you appear to give them credit for. They have their parents and the JW organisation well sussed and they're playing them at their game."

    Scoobydon't,

    You're absolutely correct. I've told them as much, that they're positively brilliant in leading a double life, playing the game. Just imagine the two homosexuals who served on the so-called governing body, how conflicted their lives became, and the cleverness they developed in hiding their actual nature, leanings.

    I don't object to these three young people's classification as disabled, either. They truly are, although, you would never guess it with a first impression. None of them can successfully exist on their own.

    Another set of in-laws raised their nominal JW family in another way, aided by the fact that the husband was known to just being going along with his wife, not an actual JW. All of the boys went out for football with the family's at every game Friday night. There was no actual studying or understanding of JW beliefs, just respect for the religion. When approached about it, the family would shrug their shoulders and say they believed everything JWs taught, just found it too hard to live the religion. This family was never hassled about their duplicit lifestyle, just accepted for being JWs in name only.

    Now, after all these years, with the kids all long gone, the elderly couple is back at the Kingdom Hall. An elder and his wife are "studying with them." Go figure.


  • sir82
    sir82

    I think more and more JW kids, with access to information not even remotely possible just a decade or 2 ago, are going to follow a similar path - avoiding baptism so that they can preserve a family relationship.

    There's a 19 year old kid in our congregation that I'm about 80% certain is following that path. Not baptized & really doesn't seem to care much about it. Gets a token amount of field service each month (he is an unbaptized publisher), never comments at meetings. Nice kid, not "immoral" at all, just simply not interested in being a JW. Still lives with parents while attending community college, I think he plans to transfer to a 4 year school once he has his 2 year degree.

    Kids are watching. In a few years, when his baptized friends start getting into trouble & losing family contact, he'll still able to have a full relationship with his family. The younger generation will watch & learn.

    And as similar examples become known thru the internet, I suspect more and more kids will follow suit.

    Prediction: Future WT articles will contain increasingly shrill and threatening articles about the "importance" of being baptized young. A 9 or 10 year old likely won't have the capacity to make such prudent choices about his future and so is more likely to get baptized, to win the approval of his parents.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit