JW Beliefs vs. welfare of a prematurely born child in Texas

by Gopher 3 Replies latest watchtower medical

  • Gopher
    Gopher

    source: www.wacotrib.com (published 12/12/2003)

    Care of premature infant transfers to Houston hospital

    By MIKE ANDERSON Tribune-Herald staff writer

    A 15-week premature Waco infant at the center of a case where his parent's faith conflicted with state child welfare laws was flown Thursday to a Houston hospital that offers specialized treatment.

    Conner Castillo was transferred from Hillcrest Baptist Medical Center to Texas Children's Hospital Thursday night after a doctor at the Houston hospital agreed to take the child as a patient. Conner's parents, Shawn and Alicia Castillo, had sought to move him to another hospital after an agreement last week had given them joint custody with Child Protective Services.

    State CPS officials took custody of Conner soon after his Nov. 16 birth when his parents would not consent to doctors' giving him blood transfusions. Weighing 1 pound, 9 ounces at birth, doctors said Conner was too small to produce blood and that he could need as many as a dozen transfusions for a chance of survival.

    Conner's parents, both Jehovah's Witnesses, said their beliefs prevent them from allowing the transfusions. Jehovah's Witnesses believe the Bible prohibits any medical practice that gives a patient blood.

    The Castillos said they wanted Conner transferred to a hospital where doctors are trained in "alternate methods" of treatment that could reduce the need for transfusions. Both parents have said the desire to move Conner is not a slight at the quality of treatment he received at Hillcrest.

    Last week's agreement between attorneys representing both CPS and the Castillos limited CPS authority over the child to giving permission for transfusions. In all other matters, such as where and by whom Conner is treated, the Castillos have the final word.

    Alicia Castillo said that since the agreement was finalized, she and her husband have worked on the transfer. Initially the couple had hoped Conner would be accepted at Fort Worth's Cook Children's Medical Center, but early Thursday they learned that fell through, she said.

    "(Hillcrest doctors) started checking into the Houston hospital, and then we just waited all day," Alicia Castillo said. "Then late in the afternoon, a nurse called us and said a team from Houston would arrive in 10 minutes to begin getting ready to move him.

    "We just started throwing clothes into a suitcase and drove to the hospital."

    The Castillos, other relatives and Conner's two brothers, 19-month-old Aaron and 14-year-old Ryan, waited outside Hillcrest's neonatal intensive care unit as the transfer team prepared Conner for the trip.

    Shawn Castillo said everyone was relieved at the chance for the specialized treatment, but nervous about the transfer.

    "My wife said it feels like something has been lifted off of her," he said. "We are blessed. He has been making progress. He gained back the weight he lost after he was born, and now he has gained a little more. As for Ryan, you can see that emotionally this has taken its toll. When people ask him, he says he is strong in his faith. But he's worried about his little brother. He doesn't like to see his brother in the hospital hooked up to all those tubes."

    Medical workers took Conner to the airport by ambulance. The family followed, with plans to drive to Houston once the plane was in the air. Alicia Castillo said she will stay with friends in Houston, while her husband will go down on the weekends when work lets out.

    The rest of the family will have to drive down to see him when they can.

    "I'm torn," said his grandmother, Sinda Castillo. "He's going somewhere where hopefully some good things are going to happen for him. But its such a long way away from his grandmother. It's hard."

    Mike Anderson can be reached at [email protected] or at 757-5755.

  • Gopher
    Gopher

    From the DALLAS Morning news...

    Source: http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dallas/tsw/stories/120703dntextransfusion.a6055.html

    Deal reached in care of Jehovah's Witness baby

    07:28 PM CST on Saturday, December 6, 2003

    Associated Press

    WACO ? The state has reached a tentative agreement with a Jehovah's Witness couple who have opposed blood transfusions for their son born 15 weeks premature.

    The agreement reached Thursday between attorneys for Child Protective Services and Shawn and Alicia Castillo clears the way for the couple to transfer their son to a Fort Worth hospital. Doctors there are trained in alternate methods of treatment that could reduce the need for transfusions.

    The deal allows the state to authorize blood transfusions that go against the parents' religious beliefs.

    Jehovah's Witnesses say the Bible admonishes believers from allowing any medical practice that gives a patient blood, according to a Web site authorized by the faith.

    The order was to be signed by the judge Friday after minor details were resolved, the Waco Tribune-Herald reported.

    Child Protective Services took custody of 1-pound, 9-ounce Connor soon after his Nov. 16 birth because his parents refused to allow transfusions.

    Connor was too small to produce blood and needed a dozen or more transfusions to survive, doctors argued in court documents.

    Connor has continued to receive transfusions and remains in an incubator at Hillcrest Baptist Medical Center in Waco.

    Representatives from both sides say the original removal order reflects a medical issue and does not indicate any abuse by the Castillos.

    More than 50 friends, relatives and fellow worshippers packed Waco's 74th State District Court on Thursday to listen to Judge Alan Mayfield go over the agreement.

    The order says the state will act as Connor's custodian only when doctors feel a transfusion is needed. The parents will be in charge of all other matters, including where and by whom Connor is treated.

    The order also says that when doctors give Connor blood, it should be no more than medically necessary.

    "This type of case, where there's a clash between medical legal requirements and religious beliefs, can become uncomfortable," said W. McNab Miller III, the couple's Houston-based attorney.

    "Delightfully, no one ran roughshod over the religious beliefs of the family," Mr. Miller said.

    Mr. Miller told the Tribune-Herald that he has handled about 10 such cases in Texas involving infants of Jehovah's Witnesses, and usually courts will approve seeking such alternative treatments.

  • Gopher
    Gopher

    Will the parents be reprimanded or DF'd for striking this deal with the authorities?

  • Sam Beli
    Sam Beli

    Probably not. The WTS wants to forget that these situations exist. The parents have no choice really and the WTS knows that.

    Lets hope that this baby survives such an early birth.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit