burned alive

by peacefulpete 2 Replies latest watchtower bible

  • peacefulpete
    peacefulpete

    As an enlightened society we shudder at the barbarism of the past. Stories of witch trials and death by burning curdle our blood. Similar modern excesses in fanatical Muslim states have mobilized human rights organizations to act in behalf of the victims. The world hears cases of adulterous wives being tortured to death and rightly responds with just indignation. But what does the Bible say on the matter? Gen 38. Judah accuses Tamar of being a prostitute and, being a God fearing man, cries for her to be burned alive! Notice what the Jewish Encyclopedia has to say about the practice:

    Only in comparatively few instances is the particular mode of death incurred by the commission of a crime prescribed. Blasphemy, idolatry, Sabbath-breaking, witchcraft, prostitution by a betrothed virgin, or deceiving her husband at marriage as to her chastity (Deut. xxii. 21), and the rebellious son are, according to the Pentateuchal laws, to be punished with death by stoning; bigamous marriage with a wife's mother and the prostitution of a priest's daughter are punished by burning; communal apostasy is punished by the sword. With reference to all other capital offenses, the law ordains that the perpetrator shall die a violent death, occasionally adding the expression, "His (their) blood shall be upon him (them)." This expression, as we shall see presently, post-Biblical legislation applies to death by stoning. The Bible speaks also of hanging (Deut. xxi. 22), but, according to the rabbinical interpretation, not as a mode of execution , but rather of exposure after death (Sanh. vi. 4, 75b).

  • peacefulpete
    peacefulpete

    Note this interesting opinion.............Of the four modes of capital punishment?stoning, burning , slaying, and strangulation?the first is considered by the majority of Rabbis the severest; the last, the mildest (Sanh. vii. 1, 49b et seq.).

    I'm pretty sure I would rather have been killed with a sword than strangled, how about you?

  • Faraon
    Faraon

    PP,

    I followed your thread at http://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/view.jsp?artid=128&letter=C . I noted that they dealt with incest by burning the transgressors. What struck me is the use of ?criminal conversation? instead of ?sex?. Another thing is that Leviticus 21:9 'If a priest's daughter defiles herself by becoming a prostitute, she disgraces her father; she must be burned in the fire.' Says that she will be burned, but only if she becomes a prostitute, yet according to rabbinical laws, there is no difference in all 10 laws mandating burning, and all are called ?criminal conversation?.

    The crimes punished in rabbinic law with death by burning are accordingly the following ten:

    1. Criminal conversation by a priest's daughter (Lev. xxi. 9; Sanh. ix. 1, 76a; Sifra, Emor, i. 14 et seq.).

    2. Criminal conversation with one's own daughter (Yeb. 3a; Sanh. ix. 1, 75a).

    3. Criminal conversation with one's own daughter's daughter (Lev. xviii. 10; Sanh. ix. 1, 75a).

    4. Criminal conversation with one's own son's daughter (Lev. xviii. 10; Sanh. ix. 1, 75a).

    5. Criminal conversation with one's own stepdaughter (Lev. xviii. 17; Sanh. ix. 1, 75a; Sifra, Kedoshim, ix. 16).

    6. Criminal conversation with one's own stepdaughter's daughter (Lev. xviii. 17; Sanh. ix. 1, 75a; Sifra, Kedoshim, ix. 16).

    7. Criminal conversation with one's own stepson's daughter (Lev. xviii. 17; Sanh. ix. 1, 75a; Sifra, Kedoshim, ix. 16).

    8. Criminal conversation with one's own mother-in-law (Lev. xx. 14; Sanh. ix. 1, 75a; Sifra, Kedoshim, ix. 15).

    9. Criminal conversation with one's own mother-in-law's mother (Sanh. ix. 1, 75a; Sifra. Kedoshim, ix. 17; Yeb. 21a et seq.).

    10. Criminal conversation with one's own father-in-law's mother (Sanh. ix. 1, 75a; Sifra, Kedoshim, ix. 17; Yeb. 21a).

    The nine cases of incest here enumerated (2-10) subject the perpetrator to the penalty of burning only when the crime is committed during the life of his legal wife (Yeb. 95a; Sanh. 76b; see Maimonides, "Yad," Issure Bi'ah, i. 5).

    The following six crimes are punished by strangulation

    1. Adultery (Lev. xx. 10; Deut. xxii. 22; Sanh. xi. 1, 52b; Sifra, Kedoshim, ix. 11; Sifre, Deut. 241; see Adultery).

    2. Bruising a parent (Ex. xxi. 15; Sanh. xi. 1, 84b; Mek., Mishpatim, 5).

    3. False prophecy (Deut. xviii. 20; Sanh. xi. 1, 5, 89a; Sifre, Deut. 178).

    4. Insubordination to supreme authority; "Zaken mamre," (Deut. xvii. 12; Sanh. xi. 1, 87a; Sifre, Deut. 155).

    5. Kidnaping (Ex. xxi. 16; Deut. xxiv. 7; Sanh. xi. 1, 85b; Mek., Mishpatim, 5; Sifre, Deut. 273; see Abduction).

    6. Prophesying in the name of heathen deities (Deut. xviii. 20; Sanh. xi. 1, 5, 89a; Sifre, Deut. 178).

    I wonder how many Eviltowerites would survive strangulation.

    I'm pretty sure I would rather have been killed with a sword than strangled, how about you?

    It depends how good was the swordsman, how sharp was the sword, and where was the sword supposed to be used.

    Faraon

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit