Correcting Deceptions in Recent Magazines

by metatron 8 Replies latest jw friends

  • metatron
    metatron

    Ordinarily, there are so many half-truths and deceptions in each Awake or Watchtower

    magazine, that it's scarcely worth the effort to point them out. However, two recent

    statements seem particularily misleading.

    In the Jan. 1 04 Watchtower, this statement is made:

    "The chaos of the second world war did not cause Christians [note the narrow and

    judgemental use of that term] to doubt that the good news would be preached" (pg. 15)

    This assertion presents people with an image of wisdom that the facts of history

    don't justify. Rutherford himself told Frederick Franz "It looks as if the great multitude

    is not going to be so great after all." ( pg. 171 Proclaimers book). The Society whipped

    up crude falsehoods that naive people believed , with cartoons of Fascists and priests marching

    off into Armageddon. The booklet "Face the Facts"(1938) told young Witnesses to hold

    off marriage until the brief period before Armageddon passed ( the book Children

    did much the same). These remarks caused them trouble in Korea as brothers took

    the words seriously ( 1988 Yearbook pg. 149) They got thru WW2 the same way they've

    survived every other crisis they've faced: scamming publishers with talk of the End, Soon!

    Another notable bit of foolishness can be found in the Jan 22 04 Awake on page 28.

    Under "Monkey Business", it recounts the efforts of some researchers to get monkeys

    to type endlessly so as to randomly produce a work of Shakespeare. The monkeys

    lost interest after 5 pages of text. This, evidently, is supposed to disprove what?

    Evolution? I'm no fan of Dawkins or Darwin but this is sheer nonsense. The inability

    or disinterest of monkeys in typing HAS NOTHING TO DO with a simple ANALOGY

    of how order can be randomly produced. That isn't the point!

    This also is the Awake featuring a brother who was a nuclear scientist. I wonder

    if he ever feels 'used' shilling for this sort of propaganda.

    and so it goes....

    metatron

  • minimus
    minimus

    The Society has always made pronouncements as if they were gospel truth. They just don't expect people to check things if THEY say it....Regarding the scientist that thought 1914 could be disproved mathamatically, but then realized he had been wrong-----all I can ask is,"Who is this guy?" Maybe he should read some other literature that could show him the error of the Watchtower's math.....Met, you should devote a weekly thread to exposing more of these types of deceptions.

  • rocketman
    rocketman

    "The Monkeys lost interest after 5 pages of text"....I wonder how long it takes humans to lose interest in reading Awake? My guess is after about two paragraphs of text.

  • blondie
    blondie

    I understand that Rutherford drew those cartoons about Religion (an archbishop), Big Business (a big-bellied manin a suit) and Pollitics (a thinner big-nosed man). He was always ranting about this trinity.

    Blondie

  • minimus
    minimus

    All the monkeys fell asleep while reading AWAKE! And they say monkeys aren't that intelligent......

  • larc
    larc

    This is not recent, but Rutherford predicted that Germany would win World War Two. He did not cite scriptures. It was just his opinion. He was bad at both scriptural interpretion and nonscriptural interpretation.

  • johnny cip
    johnny cip

    well without looking it up. rutherford did propheiced hilter winning ww2, and taking over america and britian just before the big A. and rutherford used daniel and the verses about the king of the north. and others verses to prove these ideas, from the bible... in fact rutherford even said angels gave him this info. from wt material from the mid 30- LATE 30'S just a a side note: at the 1935 144000 convention rutherford went asw far as to say arians(germanic people) were jehovahs choosen race,and all people of color will shortly be made pure in color ie:araians..etc.john

  • sf
    sf

    johnny,

    How the hell are you babe? Hugs to all!

    sKally

  • bebu
    bebu

    Hey Johnny

    Could you give the references for the comments you made? They would be very helpful!

    I always like the gems you produce.

    bebu

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit