New Cult Tactic?

by Big Jim 5 Replies latest jw friends

  • Big Jim
    Big Jim

    My daughter was babtised at the Houston Disrtict Assembly over the weekend so I was more or less forced to make that one day attendace.

    There was a pioneer sister who was explaining how she was getting so many Japanese and Phillopino Bible Studys.
    She said that her and her husband took some foreign language classes so they could at least communicate with these people a little.

    Here is what they do; they find these ones that speak very little English and they tell them they are going to help them to speak english by studying the Bible with them.

    That really blew me away when I heard that.
    Should It Have?

  • Maximus
    Maximus

    One of the big appeals to Asian immigrants is their desire to Americanize. They tend to be very receptive to the neighborly approach and the big promise that they will be equals in society overnight.

    Remember that the Mexico branch was for many years simply a cultural organization that taught folks to read. Right?

    A very old tactic.

    M

  • VeniceIT
    VeniceIT

    Ohhh ya my aunts do that. They're in a college town and ehav a lot of Chinese students, that want a way to learn english, kinda sick wehn you think about it, exploiting them like that!

    Ven

    "I'm gonna wash that borg right out of my hair,I'm gonna wash that borg right out of my hair,I'm gonna wash that borg right out of my hair, and send it on it's way"

  • tergiversator
    tergiversator

    It sounds like something I remember hearing about, so it doesn't surprise me, but...

    I wonder about the motivation on the flip side of the deal, with the sister who is learning the foreign languages in the first place. It seems to be rather popular to learn foreign languages to "help out" other language congregations, which has several nice results:

    People think you're reaching out, and you gain some sort of status.

    Learning a new language and meeting people from a different culture is certainly more exciting than field service as usual. Especially since non-English speakers in the US (probably similar elsewhere) are much more likely to agree to studies. (Probably because they want to learn English, or be American, or what have you.)

    Best of all, because you don't know the language very well, you don't notice disturbing phrasing or subtle propagandistic techniques of the magazines that you would probably have picked up on in your native language.

    I know about the last one from personal experience, because in my junior and senior years of high school I subscribed to the Watchtower in French (got the cassettes, too). It helped me learn the language, impressed my family, the congregation, and my teacher, made meetings bearable when I took notes at meetings in French... and put off for a little while admitting to myself that I wasn't so keen on the English-language stuff being presented. Towards the end I started annotating my notes with pointed comments and questions, in French, because I knew my mother wouldn't lean over and happen to see what I was writing.

    Somewhere in there I figured out that I didn't believe it was the truth, in any language. It just took a little longer.

    -T.

  • outnfree
    outnfree

    Big Jim,

    I remember reading about this tactic before -- maybe in a magazine?

    Anyway, the added benefit to the Asian immigrant is that they become familiar with the Bible, an important influence on Western society, and usually a book with which they are not familiar.

    outnfree

  • willy_think
    willy_think

    the police call that con "the bait and switch"

    the ideas and opinions expressed in this post do not necessiarly represent those of the WTB&TS inc. or any of it's subsidiary corporations.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit