Did Christ and the Jews commonly speak Aramaic, Hebrew, or Greek?
Greetings group
Ever since the movie on the Passion of Christ, I have been interested in why it is that the majority of Scholars have thought that Aramaic was the language that Jesus mostly spoke and taught in. I am not at all saying that it was not spoken at all in the area, however, when reading the bible and noting what it has to say on this subject indirectly, the evidence seems to point to the languages of Greek and Hebrew being the common languages of the Jews of that time.
Note first, an event recorded in scripture that took place in the times of King Hezekiah and the prophet Isaiah.
ESV Isaiah 36:11 Then Eliakim, Shebna, and Joah said to the Rabshakeh, "Please speak to your servants in Aramaic, for we understand it. Do not speak to us in the language of
From this text we can see that these 3 educated Jews who served in official positions in the city of were able to speak both Hebrew and Aramaic, and it is clear also in this text that both the bible and the Jews made a clear distinction between the language of Aramaic, (Gr. Syristi) and Hebrew. It is also noteworthy that Eliakim, Shebna, and Joah wanted Rabshakeh to speak in a language that the Jews would not understand, namely, Aramaic, instead of the language of the Jews, which was Hebrew.
One WT publication made this observation about the languages of the Jews.
?Later, in the days of the Jewish kings, Hebrew came to be known as ?the Jews? language.? (2 Ki. 18:26, 28) In Jesus? time, the Jews spoke a newer or expanded form of Hebrew, and this still later became a rabbinic Hebrew. However, it should be noted that in the Christian Greek Scriptures, the language is still referred to as the ?Hebrew? language, not the Aramaic. (John 5:2; , 17; Acts 22:2; Rev. 9:11)?
We can also look at the evidence in the NT to see that the languages that the bible seems to indicate that were spoken at the time of Jesus were Hebrew, Greek, and Latin.
Note first Acts 21:37, which identifies Paul as speaking both Greek and Hebrew, and that the Jews, and perhaps even the Roman officer, understood the Hebrew language that he spoke.
*** Rbi8 Acts -22:2 ***
37 And as he was about to be led into the soldiers? quarters, Paul said to the military commander: ?Am I allowed to say something to you?? He said: ?Can you speak Greek? 38 Are you not really the Egyptian who before these days stirred up a sedition and led the four thousand dagger men out into the wilderness?? 39 Then Paul said: ?I am, in fact, a Jew, of in Ci·li´cia, a citizen of no obscure city. So I beg you, permit me to speak to the people.? 40 After he gave permission, Paul, standing on the stairs, motioned with his hand to the people. When a great silence fell, he addressed them in the Hebrew language, saying:
22 ?Men, brothers and fathers, hear my defense to YOU now.? 2 (Well, when they heard he was addressing them in the Hebrew language, they kept all the more silent, and he said:)
Acts 26:14 shows that the resurrected Christ, when he spoke to Saul, spoke to him in the Hebrew language, with again, no mention of the language of Aramaic.
*** Rbi8 Acts 26:14 ***
14 And when we had all fallen to the ground I heard a voice say to me in the Hebrew language, ?Saul, Saul, why are you persecuting me? To keep kicking against the goads makes it hard for you.?
Act 6:1 talks about 2 different languages that the Jews were speaking, namely, the Greek and Hebrew speaking Jews, with no mention again of a group of Jews who were speaking Aramaic, which we would expect to find if the majority of Jews were in fact speaking Aramaic. Either, that, or we are to belief that the Aramaic speaking Jews were not ever causing trouble.
*** Rbi8 Acts 6:1 ***
Now in these days, when the disciples were increasing, a murmuring arose on the part of the Greek-speaking Jews against the Hebrew-speaking Jews, because their widows were being overlooked in the daily distribution
John 19:13-14, as well as John 5:2, make mention of only the Hebrew language, with again, no mention of Aramaic.
*** Rbi8 John 19:13-14 ***
Therefore Pilate, after hearing these words, brought Jesus outside, and he sat down on a judgment seat in a place called The Stone Pavement, but, in Hebrew, Gab´ba·tha. 14
*** Rbi8 John 5:2 ***
2 Now in at the sheepgate there is a pool designated in Hebrew Beth·za´tha, with five colonnades.
The text of Revelation 9:11gives Christ 2 names, one in Greek, and another in Hebrew. If the Jews were in fact speaking Aramaic, than you would expect John to tell us what his name in that language would be. But again, only Hebrew and Greek are identified for the reader.
*** Rbi8 Revelation ***
In Hebrew his name is A·bad´don, but in Greek he has the name A·pol´lyon.
Also, Revelation 16:16 speaks of only the Hebrew language.
*** Rbi8 Revelation ***
16 And they gathered them together to the place that is called in Hebrew Har?Ma·ged´on.
John 20:16 clearly identifies a language that Mary spoke to the risen Lord, which was Hebrew, showing that Mary at least spoke Hebrew, or was knowledgeable of Hebrew, and this text also tells us that John likely did not write in Hebrew but in Greek, since he writes that it was Hebrew that she spoke this word in, which, if he had wrote in Hebrew, he would not have had to identify.
*** Rbi8 John ***
Jesus said to her: ?Mary!? Upon turning around, she said to him, in Hebrew: ?Rab·bo´ni!? (which means ?Teacher!?)
Perhaps one of the more important verses in identifying the languages of the land, are the languages mentioned at John 19:17-21. Since Pilate wrote in Hebrew, in Latin, in Greek, so that the Jews could read the title, we would expect Pilate to have written in the common languages of the people. It is of great interest to note that we don?t find any mention here of Aramaic, which we would expect to see if in fact that was the common language of the Jews.
*** Rbi8 John 19:17-21 ***
17 And, bearing the torture stake for himself, he went out to the so-called , which is called Gol´go·tha in Hebrew; 18 and there they impaled him, and two other [men] with him, one on this side and one on that, but Jesus in the middle. 19 Pilate wrote a title also and put it on the torture stake. It was written: ?Jesus the Naz·a·rene´ the King of the Jews.? 20 Therefore many of the Jews read this title, because the place where Jesus was impaled was near the city; and it was written in Hebrew, in Latin, in Greek. 21
It would be of interest to me to understand why the majority of Scholars believe that Christ spoke in Aramaic, as well as the majority of Jews of that day. Since the LXX was the bible that the NT writer often quoted from, as well as the Hebrew Text, it would seem that the Jews would be able to speak those languages, since the NT authors wrote and quoted from those languages. Also, the written texts of Hebrew and Greek would have a preserving effect on the languages, allowing the Jews to preserve them in spoken form. The evidence in the NT also points to Greek and Hebrew as being the languages commonly spoken at the time, as well as the only languages specifically mentioned by the NT authors, besides the mention of Latin at the crucifixion of Christ. Since the bible does show that Hebrew and Aramaic are distinct languages, although similar, the text of Isaiah 36:11 seems to shows that a speaker of Hebrew would not understand Aramaic. Had Aramaic been the common language of the time, as the movie ?The Passion of the Christ? displays, we would expect to see its common usage by the biblical authors, who were also Jews and who wrote to the Jews. However, the evidence in the bible seems to point only to Hebrew and Greek, which are the languages that the oldest text of the bible, with the exception of the Aramaic Targums and parts of the writings of Daniel. Since the NT authors mentions only the Hebrew and Greek languages as being spoken by the Jews, I submit that Christ did in fact not speak in Aramaic, but in the common languages of the Jews, which NT biblical evidence indicates to be Hebrew, and perhaps some Greek, since Acts 6:1 tells us of only two categories of Jews, namely Greek-speaking Jews, and Hebrew-speaking Jews.
Free in Christ
Daniel Michaels