Newspaper article about Jehovahs's Witnesses

by Preston 7 Replies latest jw friends

  • Preston
    Preston

    Here is an article I found in the Scottsdale Tribune of Arizona about Jehovah’s Witnesses. It was located in the Editorials section. I think you will find it fascinating. By the way, if you would like to send a reply to the Newspaper that printed the article please send it to [email protected]

    The following article was written by Bill Underwood.

    I just love those calendars that tell you what things have happened in earlier years, “On this day in history …” As July 4 approaches, of course, everyone’s thoughts turn to the signing of the Declaration of Independence. But other important events mark this date as well.
    President Calvin Coolidge was born on July 4 (1872). The deaths of Presidents John Adams and Thomas Jefferson (both July 4, 1826). Isn’t that weird? I think they were on the same plane that crashed, but I could be mistaken. And President James Monroe (July 4, 1831).
    While the presidents presumably didn’t plan the dates of their births or deaths, “This Date in History” pages list many events that fell on July 4 because they were planned to do so. Among these would be the retiring of Lou Gehrig’s uniform number (1939), the start of construction on the Erie Canal (1817), the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad (1828) and the Oakland Bay Bridge (1933).
    If you don’t have a day off, hopefully it is some consolation to think about the construction workers on those earlier projects.
    And item that is all but overlooked that, I think, falls into this later category was on July 4, 1918: the shipping off to federal prison of eight officers of a corporation known as the Watchtower Bible and Tract Society, to begin 20-year sentences. I have no proof it was planned to occur on that most patriotic of days, but I can’t believe that the judge in the case was unaware of the details of how his sentence was going to be enacted.
    The “crime” with which these men were charged was the publishing of books that said, in effect, that someday God would overthrow all governments of Earth and set up his own. The government labeled such writings sedition.
    According to my dictionary, sedition is “actions or words intended to provoke or incite rebellion against government authority.” By that definition, the Declaration of Independence was seditious.
    But the clarification of the freedoms of speech and press embodied in the Bill of Rights wasn’t to happen until the 1940’s. Ironically, that clarification came at the urging of the same group of Bible students who brought some 30 cases before the supreme court between 1938 and 1943.
    An article in the May 30, 2000, issue of USA Today stated, ”So frequently did the Witnesses raise core First Amendment issues that Justice Harlan Fiske Stone wrote, ‘The Jehovah’s Witnesses ought to have an endowment in view of the aid which they give in solving the legal problems of civil liberties.’”
    Back in 1919 there were no protections. However, cooler heads prevailed and it all worked out. The eight officers were released after nine months and completely exonerated.
    Speaking of irony, one of the judges in the 1918 case, Martin T. Manton, who had been instrumental in denying bail to the eight, was later found guilty of accepting $186,000 in bribes and sentenced to two years in prison – on June 3, 1939.
    Now, obviously, someone failed to look at a calendar. They should have waited a month, ‘til July 4.

    (end of article)

    statements in bold are mine

  • Francois
    Francois

    Interesting. And your point is.....?

    Yes, the JWs have been instrumental in fine-tuning the first amendment. Naturally. It's that part of the constitution behind which they cower; it's indespensible to them. Masquerading as a religion behind the first amendment while they rake in hundreds of millions of dollars in real estate and publishing transactions is a brilliant scam.

    I might also point out that the fifth amendment was honed to its present condition via its use by the likes of Carlo Gambino, Al Capone, Frank Nitti, and others of their ilk. That doesn't make them anything but what they were: murderous, savage bastards.

    And the JWs are still a cult, no matter what they've done for the understanding of the first amendment.

    Frankly, I think it's a shame that first amendment rights are bastardized by that despicable cult.

    Francois

    Where it is a duty to worship the Sun you can be sure that a study of the laws of heat is a crime.

  • Preston
    Preston

    I know I didn't really state my opinion regarding the article. Please forgive the ambiguity of my post in that regard. The reasons why I posted it were 1.) A lot of Witnesses and even non-Witnesses are interested about hearing anything in the news about the WTBTS and 2.) as you mentioned, even though this is a religion that has been credited for doing so much for religious freedom it is debatable whether it has done much for its own members. Pushing for human rights usually identifies a person or organization as being progrssive. In my opinion, if the WBTS wants to be progressive they should have an outreach program for young people, a system that helps widows, orphans, and the needy, and a welcoming stance toward gays. I'm thinking about writing a reply where I state some thing along these lines:

    "I find it fascinating that the writer observers that July 4th should be a time for reflection on the policies that have greatly assisted religious freedom. I think it should also be utilized as a day of reflection for all of the people that have died for obeying their unscriptual command for not obtaing blood transfusions."

    Tell me, what do you think?

  • peterstride
    peterstride

    Regarding the WTS leadership going to jail, and then being released several months later...the official WTS position is that they were exonerated and released.

    In actual fact (and I'll look up the references and post them soon) they agreed to cut out several pages of the Finished Mystery book, and only after they did that, were they allowed to conditionally leave prison.

    They were never exonerated (as if they hadn't done anything wrong), but the charges were reduced as a result of them agreeing to cut out those pages.

    The Finished Mystery book predicted that the world governments would dissappear by the fall of 1920, and that god's kindom would be restored on earth.

    When that didn't happen, the book "Millions now living will never die" came out, which said that the end would come in 1925, which was the reason why millions now living wouldn't die.

    More on this shortly,

    Peter Stride
    Toronto, Canada

  • sf
    sf

    Hi Preston,

    Would you please provide the URL of said article?

    Appreciatively, sKally

  • Preston
    Preston

    Hi SF, I don't think there is a URL for the article. I'll be happy to send you a copy of the article if you want. The article was found in the editorials section of the Scottsdale Tribune on July 3, 2001, in their "A" section in the very back.

  • AngelofMuZiC
    AngelofMuZiC

    Thanks for the post. I find it very very interesting. I am going to have my mother (she's still a member) ask someone from the hall about what you said Pete.
    My Regards,
    Joanne

  • peterstride
    peterstride

    Hi all,

    I haven't had time to look up all the references I have, but one of the best is from Ray Franz's book "In Search of Christian Freedom", and here are some quotes:

    It was the publication of the Finished Mystery book that led to the trial in federal court of the Watch Tower president Rutherford and other Society officials and their subsequent impisonment.

    The Finished Mystery said, in part: "The three days in which Pharaoh's host purued the Israelites into the wilderness represent the three years from 1917 to 1920 at which time all of Pharaoh's messengers will be swallowed up in the sea of anarchy. The wheels will come off their chariots-organizations."
    "Even the republics will disappear in the fall of 1920."
    "Also, in the year 1918, when God destroys the churches wholesale and the church members by the millions, it shall be that any that escape shall come to the works of Pastor Russell to learn the meaning of the downfall of "Christianity"".
    "Not one vestige of it (Christianity) shall survive the ravages of world-wide all-embracing anarchy, in the fall of 1920."

    The book The Finished Mystery specialized in the prophecy of Ezekiel and the book of Revelation. Everything that related to Ezekiel himself was applied to Pastor Russell, the modern-day Ezekiel.

    Aside from the failed time prophecies regarding 1918 and 1920...

    The official history, Jehovah's Witnesses in the Divine Purpose (conveniently out of print for many years) actually said part of the truth as to what happenned in 1919. It says that in 1919, the brothers recognized that a compromise had been made in 1918 by cutting pages 247 to 253 of The Finished Mystery in order to please those who had assumed the position of censor.

    Today of course, the WTS says that they were released in 1919 and completely exonerated, since they had been improsoned under false charges.

    More on this later,

    Peter Stride
    Toronto, Canada

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit