A possible 'cure' for shunning?

by Jim_TX 4 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • Jim_TX
    Jim_TX

    As a youngster... I remember seeing a movie called 'Fiddler on the Roof'.

    In that movie - about a Jewish family... three daughters who get married... one goes off and follows her heart - which means that she goes against 'tradition' of the Jews.

    As a result - her father - does the 'jewish' thing... and rips his garments while saying "I have no daughter." (Very melodramatic.) He then shuns her.

    (Sound familiar?)

    My mother... a devout JW - thought that was terrible for him to do that to his own daughter.

    Okay. Here is an idea. For those that are about to be shunned... or who can still get their JW rellies - who do the shunning - to do so...

    Get them to watch this movie... or, another one is... "The Jazz Singer" with Neil Diamond. Same principle - his father shuns him - because he goes off and does his own thing.

    What I have noticed is that people - in general - will tend to get engrossed in movies... sometimes taking the side of the 'underdog'.

    Once they watch a movie like this... then one could simply ask the question... "How ridiculous. Look at how that religion, and its' teachings divides a family."

    I know that I am not thinking this through all the way... but it seems to me that movies like this might be the way to at least start 'cracking the ice', so to speak.

    Regards,

    Jim TX

  • under74
    under74

    Hmmm, interesting. You know whenever I thought of my grandfather shunning us I always tended to think of The Color Purple and the character Shug being shunned by her minister father...

  • candidlynuts
    candidlynuts

    um.. it prolly wont work.. the comments i've heard from witnesses about other shunnings is " why do they bother shunning , they dont have the truth " or " ones just as evil as the other, its stupid for those people to shun" or the main one. " if you didnt want to be shunned you shouldnt have sinned"

  • Incense_and_Peppermints
    Incense_and_Peppermints
    it seems to me that movies like this might be the way to at least start 'cracking the ice', so to speak.

    the one difference between all these examples and the witnesses is that the people who shut out their children did so of their own free will... Jehovah's witnesses shun their children 'cause that's what good witnesses do, for the good of the flock.

    screw 'em...

  • JustTickledPink
    JustTickledPink

    It wouldn't make a lick of difference to my mom. I don't think she sympathizes with anyone but herself.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit