A Surprizing Lack of Violence

by metatron 2 Replies latest jw friends

  • metatron
    metatron

    One subject I've never seen addressed on these boards
    concerns violence - or rather the lack of it - in
    response to injustices within the organization.

    This is a touchy area, I realize. I had a roommate
    at Bethel once who got booted for threatening a factory
    overseer - probably best for all concerned that he
    left.

    It might surprize you to know that the organization
    has defended violence/self-defense at times.
    For example, in resisting rape -- or many years
    ago when Rutherford thought whacking loud mouth
    Catholics was a good idea, at Madison Square Garden.
    (The Olin Moyle letter may refer to this incident).

    I don't advocate anything illegal here.

    But I would like to repeat the story of Madame DuBarry.

    Madame DuBarry was an aristocrat during the French
    Revolution. She was known to be kind and generous,
    unlike those who said 'let them eat cake'.
    The Revolution became extreme, condemning anyone who
    had anything to do with aristocracy, including her.
    On her way to the guillotine, she protested and screamed.
    She shrieked and thrashed while they cut off her hair
    and fought her executioners hysterically.

    The crowds who observed this were repelled. It wasn't
    pretty and they expected the well-born to go to their
    deaths as if they deserved it. After her death,
    the Revolution's interest in these lurid spectacles
    declined - they weren't fun anymore.

    Wouldn't it be wonderful if every Witness who has ever
    been harmed by the Society acted like she did? Wouldn't
    it be great if every judicial committee had to
    confront this kind of scene?

    Wouldn't the whole organization be the better for it?

    metatron (liberty, equality, fraternity)

  • peterstride
    peterstride

    Wow...what you posted got me thinking.

    If everyone that was going to be DFd acted up, how much could the elders stomach before asking NOT to be on any more judicial comittees?

    Hmmmmm.......

    Peter Stride
    Toronto, Canada

  • patio34
    patio34

    Metatron,

    What an intriguing thought! It would surely make a difference. Drawing a lesson from history and someone else's experience. JWs are so indoctrinated to be 'sheeplike' they just go off df'd or da'd often in the same manner.

    And the 'fight' would be things like talking to the press, trying to get anybody and everybody interested by being involved, WRITING LETTERS TO THE EDITORS OF NEWSPAPERS, etc.

    I think I'm beginning to feel inspired to action by this!

    Thanks!

    Pat

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit