LDH, I don't know where you got the idea that I feel threatened. Rather presumptious on your part to assume you know what I'm feeling, dontcha think? I'll tell you what I'm feeling, annoyed at non-English speakers in the USA who have had ample time and opportunity to learn the language of this country. Bringing up the Native American thing is pointless and I will waste no more time on it, Xena said all that needs to be said. In your last post you said "So much for the theory of the lazy Mexican." I never mentioned the lazy Mexican, no one is putting down or generalizing a group of people from any specific country. You are off-topic. You have rushed to the defense of an issue that is not being discussed here. Many of us simply feel frustrated by the fact that so many people in the USA don't speak English and that it is affecting our lives adversly. We are expressing that frustration and you are defending minorities. One does not equal the other.
Teejay, I think that deportation may be a little extreme, though I don't rule it out. I think that a basic grasp of the English language should be a prerequisite for citizenship. I think that voting ballots and DMV forms (among many other things) should be in English only, that alone would cause many people to learn English of their own will. I think that people in customer service rolls should be able to serve the customer, in America that should mean speaking English. I think that, if deportation was the punnishment for not knowing English, a very long grace period would have to be put into effect before the law was enforced, four years doesn't seem unreasonable. And also that the classes should be made free and convenient for those who would need them. Yes I think Americans should speak English. No I am not a heartless bastartd who wants to seal the boarders and who hates diversity.
COMF, I agree with you on your assesment of the English language compared to others. All the rules I learned about spelling as a child seem to have a million exceptions. Inconsistancy is the rule with English and I freely admit that I can't spell worth a damn. Kinda like the standard vs. metric thing. Standard is lame as hell. Perhaps we could continue using the English language, but just change all these stupid spellings within it, a total overhaul. I mean just look at how we spell the place where we learn English, "school." ???
Expatbrit, I have a question about "proper" English spoken by your ilk over there across the pond. What the hell is up with the invisable "R" in words that end with the letter "A"? For example:
Written: We are in America.
Brit speak: We are in America.
*compared with*
Written: America is at war.
Brit speak: AmericER is at war.
Another example from a UK band, Oasis:
Written: a champaign supernova
Brit speak: a champaign supernova
*compared with*
Written: a champaign supernova in the sky
Brit speak: a champaign supernovER in the sky
Why the ER dude?