I really want to be no part of any decision a 19-year-old young man makes which will affect the rest of his life.
That is--I don't want to tip the scale when he is in a vulnerable state. The worst decisions are made at times
where there is stress.
All I want to do and be is a sounding board for his consideration of alternate views.
____________
I keep repeating to Jordan, "Don't believe anything I tell you on face value. Please, investigate and satisfy your own mind."
The ability to make decisions does not come naturally when you've been under Authority for most of your life!
I do know until now Jordan's idea of "research" has been exclusively Watchtower publications.
Learning how to go beyond that doesn't happen overnight.
____________
I suppose what I am afraid of is crossing over from friendly sounding board to steering him.
Let's do some calculation here:
If he remains disfellowshipped he loses all the rest of his family. (Remember he's still reeling from the loss of his deceased Dad.)
He loses his "spiritual" anchor and probably his faith.
Suddenly he is raw meat. EXACTLY HOW does that "help" him?
_____________
To me, the wisest course of action is for him to take a kind of "Timeout" to collect himself. During this abeyance, he can learn to be on his
own to determine how possible/feasible such a life might well be.
Burning your bridges is almost always foolhardy.
Further, he will develop rebuttal skills and resilience as the JW buzzards begin to peck at him.
Secondarily, he might through his obstinant quest for really truthful answers, awaken in others the alarm bell that something doesn't smell right.
_______________
If I can walk the tightrope of responsible mentoring without undue influence (a fool's errand) I will have a clean conscience.