Terry, great work. I put a link to it in my notes.
However, there is one important thing you missed, partly because you concentrated on the work of Christendom's scholars.
Now, when I say this, I don't want you to go off on a loop. Stay calm. Maintain the same even keel I saw in your work. And for God's sake remember, I am not pro-wt in any manner of speaking. I am just a bible student. And I've been on this board 15 years.
Truth is truth, and it don't need a crutch. It stand up pretty good on it's own.
There was indeed a governing body in the first century.
Don't flip out. You haven't done nearly enough reading to be justified in standing on the ledge yelling 'I'm gonna jump'...
I didn't say that this group was ordained by God or desirable by Christ. Nor did I say that Acts speaks of a 'governing body' in those words.
The term, in fact, is a modern one and it comes to us honestly, via US Corporate Law. It was the "Governing Body of the Watchtower Bible and Tract Society Inc. of Pennsylvania NY", specifically the Pres, vice pres and board of directors, same as any other corporation registered in the good 'ol US of A. In the year 2000, the legal governing body stepped aside and a new governing body of the WTBTS Inc was appointed. And the spiritualized GB was invented, made up of the FORMER Pres, Vice Pres and Board of Directors.
See, I'm an 'apostate' just like you. LOL
In the first century, there was a group or body of 'governors' who asserted their power.
1) It did exist. This can be established conclusively.
2) They had activities. Also established from the scriptures.
3) The Apostle Paul expressed his view on them and their work. Established.
4) Paul sought to work with them. Established.
5) The warning we get from the account of them and their activities as well as Paul's words should dissuade any Christian group from establishing another group or body in their likeness.
The point is, what were they all about, what were their activities. How did the Apostle Paul feel about them?
That they existed and did stuff is undeniable.
There's a lot to discuss to 'get there'. I can't just paste it all. Just like when you sat down to post you spent the day, I would have to do the same. My time is tight. But I would like to discuss it.
If you are interested, then the place to start is with the 'nuclear question' ( I have a few of these I ask JW's to get them going)
The men who went down to Antioch who were trying to impose circumcision on the Gentiles... who were they?