James_Woods,
I honor your position on this subject and do fully understand your point of departure...in fact, I share it in many ways. I am just faced with the nature of these things we view as good and evil. For example; I sat in a philosopher's circle a few months back and that was the first time I'd been faced with questioning my own black and white perceptions which I was hotly contesting. The moderator posed this: There is a region in India (I believe it is the Haran?) where it is not only customary but considered the religious duty of a father to take his daughters at the onset of menses and deflower them, teaching them the ways of men. Now, that feels evil to me. Do the girls have a choice? An educated choice? But everyone around them is doing it...do they even question? I mean, is the wrongness, the invasive feeling that I have around this due to what I have been taught (that to lie with one's daughter is wrong wrong wrong?) What are those things that we do without question that others may find absolutely repulsive and predatory (i.e., I am a meat eater, but in generations to come, will humans view the eating of the flesh of other living beings as grossly distasteful?).
Then, I sat a long time with the question of Hitler....now mind you, I have a beloved son who has more than enough semitic blood to have had his head dashed against the rocks by Nazi's trying to rid the human race of "the Jewish problem".....we are taught that Hitler was wrong...he is proffered as the embodiment of evil in our time and many generations to come (YES! He feels evil to me)...but...what if the Nazi's had won? What if the version of history I learned had been colored by their philosophy?
I just dunno....
That is my struggle.
~Brigid