Your scenario is a valid one, however it has a key flaw.
The Israelites were directly chosen by god, they saw miracles, heard his voice, etc etc. Thus the kings had his backing etc etc.
The Organization was never chosen by god, there were no miracles, voices from heaven, not even a single fulfilled prophecy. The "love" within the Org is viciously used as a tool to keep people in and punish those who leave, and even that is shown to be a lie when you realize the sheer scope of the pedophile problem that has been created by the Org's rules.
1914 is a lie (research this) and copying the Israelites does not mean you ARE the Israelites!