You could ask him to show you " THE SCRIPTURE" that says humans will inherit an " earthly paradise" ?
No such scripture exists. JW`s can only refer to scriptures that they give their OWN INTERPRETATIONS too ..
When Jesus said to the person on the stake next to him "you will be with me in paradise" it could only mean ,a heavenly paradise , , why?
Simply because Jesus was never going to reside in an earthly paradise .He was going to heaven to rule not here on earth. Once he ascended to heaven that was it , he was not coming back to earth. And the person next to him was going to be with him in heaven in paradise.
I hope he reflects on his statement' I dont care if it is a cult' He might as well have said "I`m going to keep my head in the sand " or ' I`ll keep my head stuck up my arse " I choose to remain ignorant.
How do you reason with people like that
And yet the scripture says "Come let us reason together " Just another example of where they cherry pick the scriptures to suit themselves.
smiddy