We humans have no context for this. Intuition (e.g., "This computer is easy to use, it's intuitive") comes from past experience and cultural bias, core beliefs that are inculturated into us without our knowledge or awareness.
We have no personal context for stuff coming into existence without a "builder." Our only experience is that "stuff" comes into being through the efforts of a designer and a manufacturer.
We also have no personal context for the immensely long times that evolution takes place within. None of us are alive long enough to observe how successsful sports live longer and reproduce more in a particular environment and less effective individuals die off sooner with less offspring.
While we have no direct observation of God creating things, we do have a heavily biased culture that has inculcated us with beliefs.
With this constellation, I don't think we can get too dogmatic about how life began - not from a "this seems to make sense" point of view. We need to decide what to believe based on the available evidence, not what "seems to intuitively make sense."
There is a difference between evolution and abiogenesis (how life began). I am in awe over the life-patterning capabilities of DNA, how it stores information, how that info is read and converted into living creatures. I can follow the mechanics of DNA changes and how those changes alter future generations.
I'm clueless how the first DNA and processors came into being. I'm willing to wait for some evidence before deciding that came from God, happenstance or space aliens.
As far as where "the dirt" came from - I think we understand the mechanics of the formation of the solar system following the Big Bang. Like abiogenesis, I'm patient about the Big Bang itself.
Conciousness? Lots of interesting theories on that one. ;-)
Deputy Dog: There are many things that you can't see, hear, feel, smell, or taste, that can kill you. Do you doubt they exist? I would say it is likely that there are many things and forces that we are unaware of, in other parts of our universe, not to mention things and forces outside of our universe.
Certainly something we are not aware of might exist, but I would challenge the notion that there are things you cannot measure (using our senses or our tools) that can kill you. Also, I would not agree that this is a philosophical discussion.
