This is my question, if the Charles Tate Russel Bible Students were God's chosen channel and they celebrated Christmas, why would God choose a group that celebrated a so called pagan holiday? If God is without error, why would He mislead this organization? Why wouldn't He have chosen a group like the Puritans that didn't celebrate Christmas? If Rutherford changed the practice of not celebrating Christmas, doesn't that make him an apostate to Charles Tate Russel's teachings? God's chosen channel? So everyone following Rutherford should be known as apostates to the religion of Bible Students. If Rutherford was right, it still makes him an apostate to the religion the JW's were formed on.
Any other view's on this?
Cawshun