I would love to see your checklist implemented. I would also add baptizing in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit...not "spirit-directed organization."
It almost sounds like returning to how Russell had the Bible Students. They met in small groups, discussed things, didn't disfellowship others, and focused more on Jesus.
They also celebrated holidays. I see nothing wrong with allowing people to use their freedom to choose whatever their conscience allows instead of controlling people with the threat of losing their loved ones through disfellowshipping.