When I was studying with the JWs and attended my first meeting, I had two impressions:
1. Everyone loved singing all the songs.
2. I didn't know any of the words or melodies and felt really out of place.
when i was younger we had song books and i recall that some of the songs were pretty catchy.
then they revised it took some of those songs out, and added more.
i have to admit some songs were pretty good.
When I was studying with the JWs and attended my first meeting, I had two impressions:
1. Everyone loved singing all the songs.
2. I didn't know any of the words or melodies and felt really out of place.
so my wife and i just went on a walk, remember right now she has been listening to her convention.
so she starts in with the world is getting bad and will end soon.
what started it was we were talking about the economy and such.
It is ironic when you realize that you know more about WT doctrine than PIMIs do.
Not unusual, though, I've learned...
That said, for a JW not to know that the WT teaches Jesus' invisible presence starting in 1914 still amazes me.
Sometimes I think WT teaching today comes down to the noes:
-- No Trinity
-- No hellfire
-- No politics
-- No birthdays or holidays
-- No blood transfusions
maybe someone can help me here:when i got baptized at age 23, an elder dropped a bombshell on me.
he said that the new testament wasn't written for the great crowd (me).
he said that it only applies to the anointed, and "by extension" the nt applies to the great crowd.
Here's a link to a relevant talk entitled "We Wuz Robbed" by ex-JW, ex-elder Bob Gray.
Starting at 12:40, he discusses what WT doctrine robs the "other sheep" of.
Yes
question: what does the watchtower society's history of prophetic speculation prove?.
how would you respond to this answer provided by paul coom... yesterday on quora?.
"our organization has never been a prophetic speculator.
"Pay no attention to that man behind the curtain. The Great and Powerful Oz has spoken!"
i ran across a pretty early treatise.
we were all taught that "real" christianity was lost to history and was only restored once russell and then rutherford restored it so that the wt could be appointed as god's "mouthpiece".
but, aristides wrote to the emperor hadrian and gave a pretty good synopsis of core christian belief in 125 ad.
Nothing about calling God "Jehovah" and going door to door inviting people to come to God's organization for salvation?
are you sometimes dumbfounded at the direction the governing body takes?.
thousands of documents proving 607 bce is wrong, yet the gb sticks to the date, why?.
the generation that would not die, yet they continue by introducing an overlapping generation.. disfellowshipping at a time when everyone is leaving, not a good idea, yet they continue to disfellowship.. here is a video that addresses these questions.. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kbgeqhp9o9i.
In Crisis of Conscience, Ray Franz expressed the opinion that they really believe it -- victims of victims.
As the evidence grows against the WT positions, that becomes harder and harder to believe, but confirmation bias and the desire to be someone important are powerful blinders.
i really don’t know of many people who got into therapy because of their jw dealings but i would think that if someone remains depressed or severely affected by their past witness life, it’s not a bad idea to speak to someone to get you on the right path.
i think this site has been very therapeutic for many over the years..
I think the real challenge would be to find a therapist that understands how cults operate and how they affect a person's mind, will, and emotions.
i’ve noticed a change in family attitude recently, like there is just something extra on their mind.
i even had to call my brother to check if he was dying and too scared to tell me.
anyway, i saw a video last night my saying jws think we only have 12 months left before armageddon so thought maybe this is the reason for changes attitude.
When Armageddon doesn't come within 12 months, they will immediately forget that they thought it would.
most every state has a plan to get back to normalcy.
many countries also are ready to get their citizens on the road to recovery.. where does this leave the witnesses?
will they ever go back to house to house ministry?
Aren't they just rehashing Fred Franz as modified by the overlapping generation and the GB = FDS teachings?