Posts by fulltimestudent

98

Is is Muslim terrorist cafe seige Sydney...hundreds of hostages! looks bad.

by Witness 007 in

lindt chocalate cafe martin place in city people pressed against the glass with hands up...this will not end well..

fulltimestudent

Simon: FTS: posting videos of military footage set to hymn music is nowhere near equivalent. Your videos were removed because it would be far easier to find damning footage showing islam in a very bad light and there is no value in trying to "prove" any viewpoint by how much can be posted.

My post of two youtube videos, which were private person compilations set to the music of Battle Hymn of the Republic and Onward Christian Soldiers, were a response to Skeeter1's post in which he said to me:

Fulltime Student - Did the person do this crime while holding up a Christian symbol, a bible, Jesus Loves Me, writing a Christian manefesto, screaming Armeghedoon & Hell Fire, etc? I hoenstely don't know, so I ask. If he did this while holding up these symbols or shouting Christian fear-type mongering, then he should be labelled a Christian Terrorist.

I wanted to demonstrate that (as usual) there are two sides to the argument.

As I've said before, you're the boss. It's your site - I accept that you have the right of censorship. However, I think you are wrong in this case. It is not just Muslim's that have dragged religion into this dispute.

But I will leave the matter stand.

98

Is is Muslim terrorist cafe seige Sydney...hundreds of hostages! looks bad.

by Witness 007 in

lindt chocalate cafe martin place in city people pressed against the glass with hands up...this will not end well..

fulltimestudent

Cofty: A lone gunman should be shot without a second thought. Two innocent people are dead, that is a failure.

Cofty, please read the post by DJS again:

Cofty,

Ditto unless they were'nt certain that he was acting alone, which, if not, would have potentially led to the deaths of all of the hostages even if they shot him right between the eyes. If they did know he was alone, the only other thing would be whether the snipers were given the "Go" to shoot when they had a clear shot. A sniper with a clear shot without the authorization to pull the trigger, IMHO, is the likely scenario. This happens a lot, as the decision makers weigh the options and potential consequences, opportunities are sometimes missed. Stuff happens. Success has many fathers; failure is an orphan. We shall see what the officials state.

NSW/Sydney is fortunate in having a reasonably sane and seemingly honest police commissioner. I listened to his press conference this morning. Since no-one knew, at the moment that the chance shot could have been made, how many gunmen were in the Cafe, the police would have made a risk assessment. If they took him out, and that precipitated a mass slaughter of hostages by another gunman, then the police would have been called rash.

I do not know how long it took before the police became aware of who they were dealing with, but as the 'hostage-taker' expert (whose video I posted earlier) commented, everything about this seige said "amateur," and not professional terrorist.

I suggest that the police were justified in waiting it out.

I am not defending Islam, (anymore, than I defend Christian terrorism), I am attempting to use reason to view this situation.

98

Is is Muslim terrorist cafe seige Sydney...hundreds of hostages! looks bad.

by Witness 007 in

lindt chocalate cafe martin place in city people pressed against the glass with hands up...this will not end well..

fulltimestudent

Alphaman: It had to be someone picking on Islam who is at fault. Geez.

The video's I suggested, did not say that at all. The man is clearly Muslim, but the assessment of the authorities is that he was a mentally disturbed person who became a 'hostage-taker.' And, as the lecturer from Wollongong University pointed out, there are thousands of those situations around the world, every day.

About one year ago, only about 100 metres from here, and outside the Parliament building in Macquarie Street, a lone Christian, started a similar action. He claimed to have filled his car with enough explosive to destroy the building, and he threatened that he would do just that, if the government did not reverse a failed legal action he had been involved in. Much as I dislike Christianity, (nearly as much as I dislike Islam) I do not think that what this mentally disturbed 'Christain' did would justify a headline of "Christian Terrorism."

Do you?

98

Is is Muslim terrorist cafe seige Sydney...hundreds of hostages! looks bad.

by Witness 007 in

lindt chocalate cafe martin place in city people pressed against the glass with hands up...this will not end well..

fulltimestudent

skeeter1: I understand why President Obama does drone attacks that killed innocent people, and why the CIA did its interrogation methods on caught terrorists. I don't mind either.

At the risk of being flamed, may I point out that part of the problem is that many Muslims who may become disturbed enough to take action, are a mirror image of your attitude.

Every time an innocent Muslim kid is killed by a drone, the possibility exists that some relative becomes angry enough to become a terrorist.

And, I expect (in view of the above comments (and, I do understand why you made the comment) that if one of your young relatives was killed in a Muslim terrorist action, you may become angry enough to become a soldier and go and kill a Muslim in their own country.

98

Is is Muslim terrorist cafe seige Sydney...hundreds of hostages! looks bad.

by Witness 007 in

lindt chocalate cafe martin place in city people pressed against the glass with hands up...this will not end well..

fulltimestudent

And, this video of an opinion by a professional who studies hostage takers.

It was NOT a muslim terrorism action.

http://media.canberratimes.com.au/news/national-news/siege-hostage-taker-mentally-ill-6093933.html

98

Is is Muslim terrorist cafe seige Sydney...hundreds of hostages! looks bad.

by Witness 007 in

lindt chocalate cafe martin place in city people pressed against the glass with hands up...this will not end well..

fulltimestudent

Some corrections:

Two hostages dead plus the gunman.

The gunman is regarded as a mentally unstable person, who failed in a court action last week.

This video from the Canberra Times explains a lot:

http://media.canberratimes.com.au/news/nsw-news/the-moment-the-siege-broke-on-live-television-6094193.html?next_video=true

98

Is is Muslim terrorist cafe seige Sydney...hundreds of hostages! looks bad.

by Witness 007 in

lindt chocalate cafe martin place in city people pressed against the glass with hands up...this will not end well..

fulltimestudent

First, its a highly visible location, opposite the studio of a major TV station.

Second, the street, Martin Place carries a lot of symbolism in Sydney. At the top of Martin Place, there is a T intersection with a major 'Government' street with Parliament house, and in Martin Place in the next block down is a major war memorial.

I think that explains the symbolism.

29

Greek Mythology influence on New Testament

by Magnum in

a few days ago, i was in a book store, and i picked up a book providing a brief overview of classical mythology.

as i examined the opening pages, i read about tartaurus (place of punishment) and hades (god of the underworld).. it seems so odd that tartarus and hades would be mentioned in the new testament, and yet they were part of greek mythology which predated the new testament.

why would bible writers have used such terms?

fulltimestudent

Magnum: I'm still trying to process the fact that what I once so strongly believed in might not be what I thought it was. My life was profoundly influenced by the Bible for at least four decades, and now I'm beginning to have serious doubts about its being what I thought it was.

Same problem, also 40 years of mental imprisonment.

But now I am Free!

29

Greek Mythology influence on New Testament

by Magnum in

a few days ago, i was in a book store, and i picked up a book providing a brief overview of classical mythology.

as i examined the opening pages, i read about tartaurus (place of punishment) and hades (god of the underworld).. it seems so odd that tartarus and hades would be mentioned in the new testament, and yet they were part of greek mythology which predated the new testament.

why would bible writers have used such terms?

fulltimestudent

Further Jewish intermingling with other cultures and their thought.

The captivity in Babylon have brought the captive Jews face to face with another more powerful culture and the mythical stories of the Babylonians.

And, then came the defeat of the Babylonians by the Persians (Iranians). This was a powerful influence, as the Jewish writers makes Yahwehsay that Cyrus was his shepherd. (Isaiah 44:28). And that Cyrus was Yahweh's 'Christ.' It would also have brought them into contact with proto-Zoroastrianism and the idea of dualism.

98

Is is Muslim terrorist cafe seige Sydney...hundreds of hostages! looks bad.

by Witness 007 in

lindt chocalate cafe martin place in city people pressed against the glass with hands up...this will not end well..

fulltimestudent

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rw_oBXOariE