If that "no" is directed at my statement futano, I can agree with you that appeals are granted.
They are not frequent.
As you stated in a post upthread, most of the ones you yourself saw granted had to do with elders in the original committee being as you said and I quote:
More than 50% of the decisions of the original committees were totally wrong.
third world countries education is low,
those serving were end 20thies.
Where you and I disagree is in your statement above that it is the opinion or the request of the individual that generates anything.
Those two factors (the persons opinion or request) have zero to do with an appeal being granted,