Good post.
The crime it seems, is to be born in the wrong culture, with its own references of life, like worship.
It's the same today; according to most christian religions, a serial child rapist/killer can "find Christ" an hour before his execution and be "saved", while a good Hindu husband and father, helping his community all his life, will go to hell because he didn't embrace Christ while having "heard" about him (for the JWs, he will die at Armageddon for also being born in the wrong culture, as well as his wife and children along with him).
But that's Jehovah all the way. He punished Adam & Eve (and all of humanity) for eating from the tree of 'knowledge of good and bad' — while logically they could not have known what "bad" was before that!
Gods logic is weird. Before dying they "will know he is Jehovah!"
Yet dead, nobody can learn a lesson from that...