Posts by cappytan

49

Who would you vote for Today?

by James Mixon in

jw
friends

d. trump or h. clinton and why.. i would vote for gun slinging trump..

cappytan

I have a huge distaste for both of them.

Fiscally, I think Trump would be the better choice.

Foreign Policy-wise, I would pick Hilary. Not because she's strong on foreign policy. But because Trump is too much of a hot-head.

144

JW message becoming more and more relevant

by lsw1961 in

mans requirements are limited which can be satisfied with a little and tension-free endeavor..

however man attempts not only to collect but also to grab and amass everything to the excess.

somehow he feels that he can be happy only when he has in abundance whereas others have nothingwhich seems to be the thread that runs throughout the history.

lsw1961 said:

You ask “What books on evolution have you read, other than JW publications?”
The tone behind this question shows that you are very confident about truthfulness of Evolution Theory. Your confidence reminds me about same sort of confidence some great people displayed in 1923.
In that year, nine of the wealthiest people in the world met at Chicago's Edgewater Beach Hotel. Their combined wealth, it is estimated, exceeded the wealth of the Government of the United States at that time.
These men certainly knew how to make a living and accumulate wealth.
Attending the meeting were the following men:
1. The President of the largest steel company,
2. The President of the largest utility company,
3. The President of the largest gas company,
4. The President of the New York Stock Exchange,
5. The President of the Bank of International Settlements,
6. The greatest wheat speculator,
7. The greatest bear on Wall Street,
8. A member of President Harding's cabinet.
9. The head of the World's greatest monopoly
That's a pretty impressive line-up of people by anyone's yardstick.
Yet, let’s examine what happened to them 25 years later:
1. The President of the then largest steel company (Bethlehem Steel Corp), Charles M Schwab lived on borrowed capital for five years before he died bankrupt.
2. The President of the largest utility company, Samuel Insull, died penniless!
3. The President of the then largest gas company, Howard Hubson, went insane.
4. The then President of the New York Stock Exchange, Richard Whitney, was sent to jail.
5. The President of the Bank of International Settlement, Leon Fraser, committed suicide.
6. One of the greatest commodity traders (Wheat Speculator), Arthur Cutten, died insolvent.
7. The greatest “bear” on Wall Street, Jesse Livermore committed suicide.
8. The member of the US President’s Cabinet (the member of President Harding's cabinet), Albert Fall, was pardoned from jail just to be able to go home and die in peace.
9. The President of the then world’s greatest monopoly, Ivar Krueger, committed suicide.
See how soon they all changed their faith in money—how disillusioned they were! If this can happen to faith in mammon, one can imagine what will happen to faith in Evolution theory after some time. You will all look for God, and will throw away your books on Evolution.

So, you still didn't answer my question. What books on the science behind Evolution have you read that allow you to form a qualified opinion on it?

johnamos said

If we came from apes then why are there still apes??? Why haven’t they evolved??? And why is it that the so-called missing link is not in existence but apes are???

Humans did not evolve from present-day apes. Rather, humans and apes share a common ancestor that gave rise to both.

There is no such thing as a "missing link."

I ask you the same question as lsw1961: What books on the science of evolution have you read that allow you to form a qualified opinion on it?

144

JW message becoming more and more relevant

by lsw1961 in

mans requirements are limited which can be satisfied with a little and tension-free endeavor..

however man attempts not only to collect but also to grab and amass everything to the excess.

somehow he feels that he can be happy only when he has in abundance whereas others have nothingwhich seems to be the thread that runs throughout the history.

cappytan

Your evolution theory cannot explain how something immaterial evolved from something material.

That's because evolution doesn't touch on that subject. Evolution is the evidence based method of speciation. Abiogenesis is the study of how life began. Two different branches of science.

What books on evolution have you read, other than JW publications?

144

JW message becoming more and more relevant

by lsw1961 in

mans requirements are limited which can be satisfied with a little and tension-free endeavor..

however man attempts not only to collect but also to grab and amass everything to the excess.

somehow he feels that he can be happy only when he has in abundance whereas others have nothingwhich seems to be the thread that runs throughout the history.

No wonder some feel like this: "It is easy enough to make up stories of how the earth was created by a god, and to find reasons why the Bible's narrative should be trusted. But such stories are not part of science, for there is no way of putting them to the test."

Fixed that for you.

24

Massive Destruction of Judicial Files Ordered by By Servce Department?

by Room 215 in

over on the silentlambs facebook site is a copy of a document that purports to be an order by the service depart to destroy files relating to child molestation cases: https://www.facebook.com/silentlambs/photos/a.571978169529812.1073741826.144752662252367/970409503020008/?type=3&theater.

have any of you seen this?

is this a real document or bogus?.

cappytan

This is true with the exception of child abuse cases which are retained indefinitely. So records of child abuse is not being destroyed. However getting those records to court is another thing altogether.

Why aren't people getting this? Why is this checklist being used to push the narrative of them trying to cover up child abuse? It's extremely disingenuous and can be used to discredit all other evidence the exJW community has on the subject!

20

Verify the Audit Checklist/Destruction of Files!

by Atlantis in

several people have asked if the audit checklist boe/destruction of files/ can be verified.

atlantis said that if the previous information was not enough evidence, then i should send you the boe letter where the watchtower admits to sending out the annual audit inspection checklist.. .. write these down:.

.please see: page 2, number 5. please see: last paragraph on page 3.. please see: page 4 annual audit of files.

cappytan

"millions of people would agree with you flipper..."

Appeal to Popular Belief - Claiming something is true because many people believe it.

"Are you an attorney cappytan? Come back and talk to me when you are!"

Ad hominem - bypassing the argument by launching an irrelevant attack on the person and not their claim.

Those attorney's certainly don't think the BOE is "over-sensationalizing things"! They consider that BOE as an admission of guilt!

Appeal to Authority - claiming that because an authority thinks something, it must therefore be true.

"The above is your opinion! Others feel quite different than you do!"

Relativist Fallacy - rejecting a claim because of a belief that truth is relative to a person or group.

"The important fact is that the Watchtower is giving elders instructions to destroy evidence. No matter where it is taking place, the Watchtower is still trying to cover-up child abuse and save their butts in court, Period!"

Affirming the Consequent - assuming there's only one explanation for the observation you're making.

------------

I think leaks are important for the apostate cause. Keep up the good work.

However, the significance of this checklist is being seriously overblown by some apostates. There are many many more documents that are far more incriminating than this checklist. Let's concentrate on those!

For me, the only reason the leak of this checklist has any significance is because someone is inside leaking information that the society wants to remain confidential. That in itself is a victory.

20

Verify the Audit Checklist/Destruction of Files!

by Atlantis in

several people have asked if the audit checklist boe/destruction of files/ can be verified.

atlantis said that if the previous information was not enough evidence, then i should send you the boe letter where the watchtower admits to sending out the annual audit inspection checklist.. .. write these down:.

.please see: page 2, number 5. please see: last paragraph on page 3.. please see: page 4 annual audit of files.

cappytan

How is this an admission of guilt, when the checklist specifically states that things pertaining to child molestation are handled differently?

Jesus Christ, people. Use the rational side of your brain!

It is common practice for elders to purge their personal notes from time to time. My dad did so every year for 30+ years. And you know what? It's probably a good thing he did so too, because I snooped once or twice when I was a kid and saw embarrassing things about others in the congregation that should have remained private.

This whole non-story reminds me of Fox News making a big deal out of what Michelle Obama ate for breakfast or something.

Also, "millions of people" agree with flipper? I seriously doubt this document has been downloaded or viewed more than 100,000 times.

Perhaps you meant that millions of people would agree with Flipper?

68

My Explanation of God.

by LAWHFol in

i am a theist & this is my version of god.. instead of using the term god, i'll use "unseen presence".. this unseen presence, is perfect in every way.

this presence is so perfect it can seem a bit boring.this perfection can be seen in the laws of science, for example gravity.. it does not sometimes work, depending on the mood of some one in the sky, it always works, perfectly.

gravity does not get angry and decide to stop working, and cause the death of innumerable living beings, it just works, through thick or thin, it is reliable.. what allows this unseen presence to remain perfect, is the fact that it does not act based on emotion, or strategy or regret.. it acts based on law, mathematical law.. this unseen presence is not partial to jews or muslims or jw's it is completely impartial at all times, to everything that exists.

cappytan

Proof of Hitler's conscience is that even though he was mean to the Jews, at least he was nice to blonde Germans. Brilliant!

68

My Explanation of God.

by LAWHFol in

i am a theist & this is my version of god.. instead of using the term god, i'll use "unseen presence".. this unseen presence, is perfect in every way.

this presence is so perfect it can seem a bit boring.this perfection can be seen in the laws of science, for example gravity.. it does not sometimes work, depending on the mood of some one in the sky, it always works, perfectly.

gravity does not get angry and decide to stop working, and cause the death of innumerable living beings, it just works, through thick or thin, it is reliable.. what allows this unseen presence to remain perfect, is the fact that it does not act based on emotion, or strategy or regret.. it acts based on law, mathematical law.. this unseen presence is not partial to jews or muslims or jw's it is completely impartial at all times, to everything that exists.

cappytan

Show me a Man that can Hurt Another Man, without any Remorse EVER and I will show you a Man that cannot Love EVER.

It's almost as if LAWHFol has never heard of serial killers and nazis.

20

Verify the Audit Checklist/Destruction of Files!

by Atlantis in

several people have asked if the audit checklist boe/destruction of files/ can be verified.

atlantis said that if the previous information was not enough evidence, then i should send you the boe letter where the watchtower admits to sending out the annual audit inspection checklist.. .. write these down:.

.please see: page 2, number 5. please see: last paragraph on page 3.. please see: page 4 annual audit of files.

cappytan

Does it matter WHERE? The important fact is that the Watchtower is giving elders instructions to destroy evidence. No matter where it is taking place, the Watchtower is still trying to cover-up child abuse and save their butts in court, Period!

I'm pretty sure they're required to destroy these notes by the Data Protection Act. Child Abuse evidence is handled with the blue envelopes and is exempt from these rules, if I recall from another thread.

Let's not over-sensationalize things for the sake of controversy. There is plenty of other evidence that the society tries to cover things up. At worst, this document is a thin thread of evidence of ill intent and lurkers may see this and ignore the rest of the evidence because of the overreaction on our part.

Lets deal with hard, tangible evidence...like the ARC evidence. It's a waste of time to blow this document out of proportion when the support for it having anything to do with child abuse is tenuous.