Posts by Believer

133

Why Are You Here?

by Believer in

i'm wondering why believers remain members of this forum which is clearly hostile to believers.

as one member said, nonbelievers pounce on any semblance of belief like piranhas on prey.

as former jws we should have had our fill of judgmental know-it-alls, but here we are.

Thank you KateWild, but you misunderstand me. I don’t feel mistreated. You can’t feel mistreated unless you expect a certain level of treatment that you don’t get. I joined this forum with no expectations, so whatever treatment I get is just the treatment I get. Besides, it says more about the ones giving the treatment, than about those who are subjected to it.

133

Why Are You Here?

by Believer in

i'm wondering why believers remain members of this forum which is clearly hostile to believers.

as one member said, nonbelievers pounce on any semblance of belief like piranhas on prey.

as former jws we should have had our fill of judgmental know-it-alls, but here we are.

Believer

I'm wondering why believers remain members of this forum which is clearly hostile to believers. As one member said, nonbelievers pounce on any semblance of belief like piranhas on prey. As former JWs we should have had our fill of judgmental know-it-alls, but here we are. So why? What is the attraction?

I'll answer first for me. Though I've only been a member for a few days I've been lurking for 2-3 years. One reason I kept coming back was to find out what's new in JW land. The other reason is to observe the long term effect WT theology has on people.

Jesus condemned the Pharisees because 'they traverse land and sea to make one proselyte and then made him a subject of Gehenna more so than themselves.’ At first I wondered what that meant but watching the progression of many exJWs evolve or devolve from blind faith to no faith seems to be the answer. Of course there are many who evolved from blind faith to true faith but those believers are relatively quiet here. So I guess the other reason I keep checking in, I must confess, is like the fascination of watching a train wreck. You really hope no one is seriously injured, but you just can't help looking!

So, fellow believers, that’s my reason. But why are you here? What do you get out of this forum that makes it worth putting up with the attacks from self proclaimed animals?

Oh! And Happy Fathers Day, all you beautiful children of God!!

240

Introduction - Any Believers?

by Believer in

i’ve been reading it for a few of years off and on, but have been a little too ... maybe ... timid to join.

i left the watchtower organization almost 20 years ago but never abandoned my faith and belief in god.

i knew the gb/organization didn’t represent god, so when i lost my faith in them, i managed to keep my faith in an all wise benevolent creator.

Believer

Now the ridicule starts. So typical. For your information, The Urantia Book is the only quasi-religious book that effectively answers all questions and issues of atheists. So it is understandable why atheists might not want to read it and choose to ridicule it instead.

And, fyi, it was written by contemporaries and eyewitnesses, but not type a non-believer would accept. But certainly the type that would be required to know the things it covers.

Anyway, have a good day my new friends. I’m going to spend time with my grandson!

240

Introduction - Any Believers?

by Believer in

i’ve been reading it for a few of years off and on, but have been a little too ... maybe ... timid to join.

i left the watchtower organization almost 20 years ago but never abandoned my faith and belief in god.

i knew the gb/organization didn’t represent god, so when i lost my faith in them, i managed to keep my faith in an all wise benevolent creator.

Believer

Simon, just take a look at the link I gave you. Chapters 122 - 135 are all about the birth to adulthood of Jesus. Practically none of that is in the NT.

240

Introduction - Any Believers?

by Believer in

i’ve been reading it for a few of years off and on, but have been a little too ... maybe ... timid to join.

i left the watchtower organization almost 20 years ago but never abandoned my faith and belief in god.

i knew the gb/organization didn’t represent god, so when i lost my faith in them, i managed to keep my faith in an all wise benevolent creator.

Believer

Better yet, when you get your quotes together, start a new thread about Jesus and the Urantia Book. This topic is about whether their are any believers who have left the WT. Let's keep the topics separate.

240

Introduction - Any Believers?

by Believer in

i’ve been reading it for a few of years off and on, but have been a little too ... maybe ... timid to join.

i left the watchtower organization almost 20 years ago but never abandoned my faith and belief in god.

i knew the gb/organization didn’t represent god, so when i lost my faith in them, i managed to keep my faith in an all wise benevolent creator.

Believer

Ok. Coffy. Let’s make this interesting. I have read all of the books in the Nag Hammadi Library. They are interesting and the meet the standard of your question – primary source information about Jesus not contained in the NT. But the book that provides the most reliable and comprehensive information about Jesus is The Urantia Book. So let’s start there. Pull out quotes about Jesus from the Urantia Book and we can discuss them.

240

Introduction - Any Believers?

by Believer in

i’ve been reading it for a few of years off and on, but have been a little too ... maybe ... timid to join.

i left the watchtower organization almost 20 years ago but never abandoned my faith and belief in god.

i knew the gb/organization didn’t represent god, so when i lost my faith in them, i managed to keep my faith in an all wise benevolent creator.

Believer

Simon, you said:

The simple fact is there is nothing beyond the myth of the bible to support the myth of the biblical Jesus.

It seems you haven’t looked into the contents of the books on the list either. Sure there are many books that are commentaries about the NT, but there are other books that are original primary source information. Take a look at the 40-50 books found in the Nag Hammadi Library.

http://gnosis.org/naghamm/nhlalpha.html

And here’s a link that I think is the most comprehensive and direct writing about Jesus containing information not disclosed in the NT.

http://www.urantiabook.org/newbook/index-biography-of-jesus.html

Now whether you accept those writings as authentic, true, or valuable is a personal observation. I won’t try to convince you either way. Read them and make your own assessment. And by the way, I have read them all and have made my own assessment. So I am coming from a place of first hand knowledge and experience, not supposition and speculation.

240

Introduction - Any Believers?

by Believer in

i’ve been reading it for a few of years off and on, but have been a little too ... maybe ... timid to join.

i left the watchtower organization almost 20 years ago but never abandoned my faith and belief in god.

i knew the gb/organization didn’t represent god, so when i lost my faith in them, i managed to keep my faith in an all wise benevolent creator.

Believer

Coffy, now who is being dishonest? I gave you a list of books that talk about Jesus like you asked. You come back with

None of the books in the google search link tell us a single thing about Jesus that does not originate in the NT. But you already know that.

How do you know that those books do not contain new information about Jesus? Did you read them? Scan the content? Or just look at the titles? I’ve read many of them so my statement is based on what I know to be a fact. You are just trying to do gotcha questions. If you’re really interested in books that give more information about Jesus outside of the NT, look, seek, knock. Put in some sweat. I gave you the link to the books and put you on the path. If you want to know more, its up to you.

240

Introduction - Any Believers?

by Believer in

i’ve been reading it for a few of years off and on, but have been a little too ... maybe ... timid to join.

i left the watchtower organization almost 20 years ago but never abandoned my faith and belief in god.

i knew the gb/organization didn’t represent god, so when i lost my faith in them, i managed to keep my faith in an all wise benevolent creator.

Believer

Good morning! This has been an interesting and informative thread. Thanks to everyone who posted their comments to my request to start a conversation about why people still believe in God after leaving the WT. Maybe we can follow up on new threads. But before I complete this one, I want to respond to a couple of questions:

Coffy and StartingOver, you asked me to provide you with a list of books about Jesus. I said, “Google it!” This morning I see that you continued to challenge me on this topic. If you had googled it, you would have seen, as probably the first entry, a link to an article by Wikipedia entitled “List of Books About Jesus.” But so that you don't have to burden yourselves with googling, here is the link.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_books_about_Jesus

*

Starting Over, you shared with me the video called “Dear Believer, Why Do You Believe.” As I said, I will look at the video and respond to the questions raised as soon as I can. I’ll start another thread on it and PM you when I do.

*

2+2=5, you said you don’t know what I believe. Here it is in a nutshell: I believe in God, but not in any particular religion. I believe God is good, wise, loving, and the first cause of everything. I believe his purpose in creating man is for man to learn to become like God experientially (perfect as he is perfect). And I believe that our life on earth is just the first leg of a long journey Godward.

*

Giles Gray, I will respond to your questions.

If "we don't have the capacity to experience spiritual things through our senses...", as you said in your earlier post, how can anyone know if a supernatural experience is authentic?

I meant that we cannot experience spiritual things through our 5 physical/animal senses – seeing, hearing, tasting, smelling, and touching. But humans have an additional sense. Some call it intuition, or the 6th sense. This 6th sense is how we perceive spiritual things. The 5 senses are objective and can be authenticated in a way that others readily accept, i.e., they can taste, touch, see, hear, smell it too. But the 6th sense is subjective. It is a personal understanding or epiphany or revelation. One person cannot prove their personal spiritual revelations to another. He may be able to articulate it, but authenticating it can only occur if the other person is also able to perceive it through their 6th sense. But a spiritual revelation is just as real to a person who uses that sense as are the things perceived with the animal senses. Its kind of like love. If I love someone, I know it. But everyone else will just have to take my word for it.

So even if an angel appeared to you, how would you know it was not some spiritual hoax by some other being acting as an angel?
If Jesus materialised right in front of you, how would or could you know that it wasn't actually Zeus playing a game?

I put these two questions together, because they are basically asking the same thing. They do not ask whether Jesus, Zeus, an angel, or being acting like an angel are real. They only ask how one can tell the difference between a good one or a bad one. It would be the same way we can tell if humans are good or bad – by their works and what comes out of their mouths.

And if Satan wrote the bible, how do you know that he hasn't tricked everyone into thinking otherwise? What valid argument could prove or disprove such a claim?

To answer that question, I’d have to assume arguendo that Satan wrote the Bible (which for the record, I reject.) But assuming he is the actual author, you ask now could I know he hasn’t tricked everyone into thinking he didn’t write it. Well, the historical record offers valid evidence that men actually wrote it. Look it up. I think that’s pretty good empirical evidence that would support the conclusion that Satan did not write it. But let’s assume you aren’t really asking who was the actual penmen, but rather are asking whether Satan inspired the writing of the Bible, and whether the thoughts and ideas in the Bible are those of Satan. Well, if that were the supposition upon which this question is based, then if Satan wrote the bible, that would be proof that God and other supernatural beings exist. Right? Well, my position is that God does exist. So if we begin with the established position that Satan is out there writing books, then my position is authenticated.

*

And that about does it. So in this thread, I discovered that there are at least 20 believers, including 4 who believe, but have doubts about the goodness of God, and at least 19 non-believers, including 1 who wants to believe, and 2 who are open to more information. 20 to 19 in favor of belief is not bad. According to this thread, the non-believers do not outnumber the believers. So maybe we can have more conversations about belief after JW. Believer Out!

240

Introduction - Any Believers?

by Believer in

i’ve been reading it for a few of years off and on, but have been a little too ... maybe ... timid to join.

i left the watchtower organization almost 20 years ago but never abandoned my faith and belief in god.

i knew the gb/organization didn’t represent god, so when i lost my faith in them, i managed to keep my faith in an all wise benevolent creator.

Believer

Giles Gray, “inspired by” doesn’t mean God wrote it. I means God was the inspiration, the muse. That’s all. People may redefine the word, but look it up in any trusted dictionary. Also when you consider the crude and elementary understanding of so many things in the Bible, its pretty clear that an all wise and loving Creator could not have been the actual author. And the Bible doesn't say that God wrote the Bible. A better example of a book written by God would be Jesus. His life was the personification of the word and will of God. And that is actually what the NT says.

Now, the questions you ask are questions that would be posed by a mind that cannot really know anything. So flighty and philosophical. Like, “How do you know that blue is really blue or just what you have been told to call blue?” It is hard to have a conversation with a mind that thinks like the wind. But let’s do this another day, when you have real questions that can spark an intelligent conversation.

Good night all.