BB,
I'm twice as old as you, plus two.
42, male, outside Boston. Belief? God and the Bible.
>>>Pomegranate, do you think that you could expand on what you believe? I have never heard that point of view and find it interesting to listen to.<<<
In order to do that, we need to go back to BEFORE the beginning of physical creation. We need to reason on the start of all things from the spiritual side of the curtain, because that is where the problem began.
I would start here:
There was God in heaven, and legions of created spiritual creatures with Him, and everything was GOOD. It will be highly important to understand the circumstances at this point in time accurately, because this is the foundation for everything to follow.
From here, I would start introducing questions and premises on what likely happened prior to Genesis 1:1, just from logical reasoning.
Remember, there is presently NO REBELLION in heaven...OK??
The first question I would ask myself is this:
Was God OMNISCIENT (All knowing) at this point in time BEFORE Satan rebelled?
I have to say to myself NO absolutely NOT for two logical reasons, God and Satan. THEY are the two reasons you ask?? Well, yes. Let's start with reasoning on the God angle. I will only use one thought pattern here, but there are more to help prove that God would not have KNOWN evil before Satanic rebellion.
IF God were omniscient at this point in time (before Satan's rebellion), that would mean He knew Satan was going to be evil BEFORE Satan in fact was evil. If that is true (God's omniscience), then that would also mean that God knew Satan was going to be evil even BEFORE God created Satan's life form. If that is true (God's omniscience), then that means the source of all evil is DIRCETLY from inside God HIMSELF, meaning God "knew" evil BEFORE it existed, meaning He is the Creator of evil and created evil into existence by forming the life of Satan. BUT....Scripture says this regarding any "evil/darkness" in God:
1 John 1:5-6
5 This is the message we have heard from him and declare to you: God is light; in him there is no darkness at all.
To me, it seems quite evident from this pattern of reasoning, that God was NOT omniscient BEFORE Satan left the way of Love, because if He was, God is Evil Himself. People who have faith in God know NOTHING evil was in or came out of God. If that is an accepted belief of ones faith, then they also have to reason that God was not omniscient before Satanic rebellion.
Now, Satan's side:
I'm NOT stupid. Neither is Satan. With that in mind, how stupid would someone have to be to rebell against A God that was omniscient. I mean, how can ANYONE even for the slightest split second think they could supercede God's will with their own will if God already had them out smarted and out thought to the point of already having the rebel "six feet under?" I'm no where near the intellectual capacity of an angel, but I feel it's a no brainer that if Satan knew the power, he would have still been washing God's floors.
So, from boths sides PRIOR to the rebellion, this line of reasoning to me points to a time that God was NOT omniscient, and God knew not the even conceptualized SMALLEST SEED of evil. There was NO SUCH THING AS EVIL in God's "mind" nor did He have the slightest seed of a hint that a being that He would create, would be responsible for the concept and creation of evil at a future time. Basically, it is something God could NOT even understand, UNTIL it hit Him smack dab in the face.
I believe one has to understand this basic scenario before building further understanding. We have to realize that evil does NOT have it's source in God. In order for that to be true, God could NOT have forknown it, which means before Satan, he was not Omniscient. As you reason on omniscience more, I think you will find omniscience is a power God created as a defense mechanism against the evil that was created by Satan. When there is all good and no bad, no omniscience. When there is both Good and bad, omniscience is one of the tools God created to GUARANTEE his will be done and Satan's will be thwarted.
OK. Reason on the above. Questions? Ask em. Comments? Say em. You want me to go on? Let me know.
PS. Maybe you wanna start a new thread on this?