Here is a post on reddit from Mark and Kimmy O’ Donnell, from the Crusaders Documentary,
Ask us
anything.
Mr. O'Donnell gives his assessment of why WT lawyers continue to defend the Child Sex Abuse cases that the Organization continues to fight, even though they see firsthand the deception, the lies, the withholding of facts and dirty tactics used in court. by an Organization that claims to be God's earthly representative, and the only one to hold the TRUTH. .
QUESTION from one poster.
My question is one
that asks for your opinion or perhaps for you to speculate a bit but
here it goes.
WT lawyers see first
hand how the deception, lies, withholding facts, stall tactics and so
on are commonly used in court. These lawyers are also JW elders I
assume, correct?
How on earth can
they see this as "giving a good witness" and how can they
expect anyone witnessing this behavior think that JW's have the
truth?
In addition, how can
these lawyers think that this behavior is honestly showing the
"Christian personality?" I would expect to see a WT lawyer
pull a "Barbara Anderson" at some point and exit the
organization for conscience related reason.
I guess my question
is, how do you think these elders/lawyers internalize their behavior
and the effect this behavior has on Child abuse victims ? To put
simply, how do they sleep at night?
ANSWER from John-Redwood
This is a really great question, and I was
just commenting on this on another person's question.
The JW Legal Department is managed by JW
elders, of course. There's a special group of these JW lawyers
handling the child abuse cases.
It's hard to say how they sleep at night. I
talk about this with the attorneys who represent victims. The ones I
work with are very moral and decent people who can't seem to
understand why the JWs are doing what they are doing.
During one trial, a trial attorney turned to
me and asked me "Why are they doing this??"
The answer is partly religious fervor- and
the belief that God is backing them, and that they have the backing
of the US Constitution. However they are learning that this is
becoming more difficult every day.
Another thing to keep in mind is that while
the Legal Department is managed by JW elders, they have FAR too many
cases to handle them alone. Watchtower hires a large number of non-JW
lawfirms in nearly every state to defend themselves in child abuse
cases. This takes some of the pressure off the JW Legal department,
but it comes at a very high price. It's taking its toll on the JW
organization, as it should.
Please remember that the JWs believe that
the confessional process is sacred, just like it is with the Catholic
church. Read 1 Corinthians chapter 6. They believe their process is
higher than secular laws. But they also use the Constitution and
secular laws to their advantage whenever possible.
The problem is that we have a conflict now,
where we have reporting laws, but we also have the
clergy-confidentiality provisions, and the organization does not want
to lose their power of confidentiality and the ability to handle
judicial cases internally, including child abuse cases. They don't
want to lose control of the whole process. They want to be able to
disfellowship a baptized 14-year-old child if they believe the child
was guilty of "willful participation" in sexual acts with
an adult or even another child.
These are some of the issues in play. But
yes- I am hoping we see a few Legal Department members wake up and
leave. You never know...