The points expressed here were my points exactly in the previous thread.
Friend emphasized the fact that the WTBTS did nothing illegal and that they made a sound business decision, which is indisputable.
I highly doubt that stumbling any of the brothers has EVER mattered to the WTBTS. How many have stumbled due to all of the flip-flops of doctrine over the years? I'm sure the number is not small.
I also doubt that the WTBTS cares a whit about any of the "sheep" it purports to shepherd. Once they get the fleece, the sheep can fall off a cliff for all they care. As long as there are untapped areas to obtain new sheep, the spiritual deaths of former flock members do not matter.
Bloodguilty? Only if their prophecies turn out to be true and all of these lapsed members are actually condemned to death at Armageddon. Implied bloodguilt, surely, since these lost sheep, by and large, do feel that they are now condemned to death....at least for some amount of time.
At the very least, they are guilty of mental torture of their members due to the trememdous amount of neuroses they engender during their incarceration within the walls of the Watchtower.