Petty,
I too was born & raised JW. Coming out I was scared to pick up any materials that were "apostate" and not WT publications. What fear they instilled in us.
After leaving the JWs I did start studying Christianity. Yes, from one religion to the next. I did that for several years, and again did not use my critical thinking and reasoning. Just went along with yet another man's rendition of the "truth".
Now I belong to no religion, I read anything I want to. I am not scared of putting "bad" information into my head. I take things with a grain of salt that I read, and I dont believe it just because I read it or because someone told me it was the way to go. I have recently done much critical study of the bible and the christian religion, and decided that maybe that was not the path for me.
There are many eternal questions in life. I dont have the answers. And neither does anyone else really. It's all just anyone's best guess. And if god is going to punish us for guessing wrong (with all of the lack of clear direction), well then geez, he's not a very nice god. I have just come to terms that there is no more black & white in my life. Life is too colorful to make everything black and white. Why cant we just ask questions and wonder. I've learned to be comfortable with not knowing.
I hope you can come to something that you are comfortable with. Just know that most of us have been where you are. And we've all taken our own path. You must do the same.
Just blabbing....
Stacey