WTwizard
This in an interesting and apt post. Among other things you say:
They should be free to rationally debate and discuss their religion with people that have different religious beliefs,
I agree with this. The difficulty is that all religions are based on faith. Faith cannot be debated rationally because it not based on evidence but on belief. If it is Christianity that is being debated, in order to find something tangible to analise most discussion end up examining the Bible, .
As soon as the bible is shown to be unreliable and contradictory many of the Christian persuasion then claim that the Bible is not to be taken literally and it is not necessary to believe it to be a Christian. Or if passages portraying God as a violent despot are quoted, they dismiss those inconvenient passages and say all you need is Faith. Or love if you believe 'the Beatles.'
So we come back to this slippery emotion called faith that is based on nothing but a warm feeling and - well - Faith!
Anyone who needs a little more to go on is attacked for lacking Faith and accused of having no morals. Even those like myself who admit that they honestly don't know what God is or much about him/her/it are dismissed as 'lukewarm' or uneducated.
In the end it leaves little left to discuss rationally. So it is back to Bible bashing and pointing out contradictions in peoples beliefs. It is a rather pointless exercise. The only entertainment value is when it gets a bit heated and the big noises kick off and and start winding each other up.
Nothing will ever be settled because people with beliefs, believe what they need to and have not the slightest interest in truth. So whats new?
Trevor