I think our emotions are "informed" by our values. What we involuntarily feel are visceral and palpable signals pointing to what we hold true, valuable, or absolute.
If I'm walking in the dark and see a coil of rope that looks like a rattlesnake, my spontaneous, instinctive visceral reaction will be a jolt of adrenaline and I'll probably jump away. No time to think about it (which is how instinct works toward survival.)
The absolute nature of our understanding of "god" is transmitted to us as kids.
A Buddhist family informs little kids of Buddhist values, a Catholic family inculcates icons, candles, etc. and so on. Our location on Earth is accidental in informing our sensibility and consequently our emotional connection with this "god" of our region and family.
So, it's not REALLY a choice in any absolute sense.
I had only the numinous emotional connection of my grandmother's Catholic experiences as related to me by her.
Then, my best friend (JW) layered on the specifics of JW cult 'data.'
All the above rather a long-winded preamble to saying this:
Left to our own devices, I think without specific indoctrinations we'd all end up with a superstitious view of how the universe 'works'.
My intellect has had to be scoured, and barnacles of Jehovah scraped off.
The emotional component is surgically bereft of any god-value.
I have no automatic emotions.
I see and hear God talk as just so much superstitious/emotional involuntary hocus pocus.
I neither argue for nor against anybody's idea of god.
I'm not interested in that.
I'm interested in people and whether their lives are benefited or crippled by god talk and belief.
Especially is this true of the JW indoctrination.
My specific 'talent' is debunking THAT.
If and when I am able--I am determined to bring a bit of sunshine to those dark prisons and allow some measure of objectivity to an extremely subjective subject.