ok I was not really going to get into this, but you drew me out.
I like the Mormon preEarthly history and their eschatology and after-life ideas. I like their Temple rituals. I like their open to spiritual experiences approach too. And I was only a few weeks off from getting married in the Temple when we moved and fell in with a bunch who were not what we were used to. A bad bishop basically. But I wrote a letter to one of the apostles and he wrote me back. Try that with JWs. The one hold up I have with any form of christianity is purely cultural. I am not Jewish. I don't want to be Jewish. And I am not into the American pilgrim and westward-ho experience either. I am Celtic, and I swear if Moroni shows some Brit where the Holy Grail is I will be the first to sign up!
Now about the early stuff...the biggest thing that bothers me is that Joseph Smith was told that if he finished the Temple in---oh what is that place? I can't think of it right now--- and only IF, they would continue to be the special people blessed with the privilege of Temple baptisms. Joseph Smith did not finish it. It was not even finished before he was killed. They basically lost the privilege of being the special ones. And when Joseph Smith was killed the next leader should have been by rights his son. that was how it was set up to pass the torch. Brigham young took a group and separated from the others in a coup and when they were out in the middle of nowhere he made himself the next leader.
As far as I am concerned that is the same thing that happened to Russell and Rutherford.
Joseph Smith never called his people Mormons, that came after Brigham Young came into it. The group that remains loyal to Joseph is still around today and are the legal owners of the Missouri Temple. And according to prophecy they do not do Temple baptisms. So in all technicality, the LDS Church should have died with Smith. I can't see this modern church as being any closer to any kind of complete truth as any other religion right now. But I do think they have something. I am not sure what it is, but it is something. I just wish I could FEEL like I belong there.
I really loved it when I was with the LDS church in VIneland NJ. But then in NH it was terrible! It was so bad that the older missionary couple who studied with me called on the phone and were worried we had fallen into an 'apostate' group. At the time I thot it was funny. But it was sad. Because we never got that original feeling back, and I miss it.
Same thing with the Catholic Church I went to after that. It was a little mission and it was great. Now we are back to giant impersonal cliquish museums...
Ravyn